Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
It is widely recognized that meaningful learning is an active process whereby new information is interpreted by the learner using existing cognitive tools and integrated within established mental frameworks through associations with prior knowledge (National Research Council, 2005). Accounting for students’ thinking is therefore essential for effective teaching, and instruction must be responsive to the changing understandings of learners (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 2000). While the literature is replete with descriptions of alternative conceptions (Pfundt & Duit, 1994), it is only recently that researchers have begun to describe the development of students’ thinking with respect to core, scientific concepts in particular contexts (Hartigan, 2010). One core, “great idea” in the sciences is the concept that all matter consists of vast numbers of continuously moving and interacting, submicroscopic particles that produce the macroscopic properties and behaviors of the materials that comprise our natural and manufactured worlds. While considerable research has explored students’ perspectives and reasoning regarding the molecular universe, little work has attempted to portray the manner in which such understandings evolve over time.
This qualitative study, whose theoretical perspective is based on the nature of understanding (Wiggins & McTighe, 1998), traced the development of students’ conceptualizations of matter at the molecular level as indicated by changes in their representations of various materials and phenomena over one academic year in high school chemistry. During that time, students received ongoing instruction regarding the properties and behavior of molecular entities. Students were also taught how to construct, test, and revise particulate-based, conceptual models to account for the properties and behavior of a wide variety of common phenomena, and their abilities to do so were regularly assessed. This approach is a refinement of the Modeling Instruction Program developed at Arizona State University, recognized by the U.S. Department of Education in 2000 as one of the seven best, K-12 educational technology programs in the nation, and again in 2001 as one of only two exemplary, K-12 science education programs in U.S. (Arizona State University, 2011).
While the specific pathway of learning experienced by each of the 105 students who participated in this study was unique, many significant patterns emerged. Over 90% came to chemistry knowing that matter consists of particles, and some were able to produce accurate representations of simple molecules, yet students generally did not view the particles in common materials as moving or interacting. With instruction and assessment in modeling molecular systems using simple, drawn representations supported by verbal descriptions, some students exhibited dramatic improvements in this regard over the first several weeks of the course. However, for most, conceptual development was evolutionary rather than revolutionary.
The results of this study focus on the prevalent patterns identified among students’ changing representations of molecular systems over nine months of modeling-based teaching and learning. This information provides valuable insights that can inform the tools and methods of instruction and assessment in this regard, and specific suggestions for facilitating and assessing secondary students’ understandings of the molecular world through the use of conceptual models are offered.