Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Reconceptualizing Communities of Practice: Literacy, Learning and Identity Development in the Council of Youth Research

Mon, April 16, 8:15 to 10:15am, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Second Level, East Room 12

Abstract

In this paper, the students, teachers, and university researchers in the Council explore how the framework of communities of practice (Lave and Wenger, 1991) can be reformulated by looking at literacy, learning, and identity development within the Council and community organizing groups. To investigate how the Council illuminates the concept of communities of practice, we sought to address the following research question: How can the literacy, learning and identity development processes in the Council help flesh out the concept of communities of practice? To answer these questions, we conducted participant observations and interviews, and collected student work products. We then analyzed the data through critical discourse analysis and ethnographic data reduction. We find that the Council not only exemplifies the concept of a community of practice, but also expands this concept through its application to youth organizing contexts.

Lave and Wenger (1991) define a community of practice as “a set of relations among persons, activity, and world, over time and in relation with other tangential and overlapping communities of practice” (p. 98). To account for the situated character of learning in communities of practice, they propose the concept of “legitimate peripheral participation” to describe the ways that individuals occupy certain positions and have certain amounts of power. Learning or development within a community of practice involves members’ changing participation in activities over time, moving toward full participation (Lave & Wenger, 1991; Rogoff, 2003).

We find in this paper that the Council exemplifies a close-knit community of practice that helps students construct empowered identities oriented toward action through the authentic learning associated with community action. Additionally, Council students inhabit various and shifting identities that develop along with their literacy learning, demonstrating that communities of practice can be much more dynamic than Lave and Wenger postulated.

This paper finds that within the Council’s community of practice, students engage in a range of both critical and academic literacy practices, including: video documentary production and distribution; the use of social networking sites to promote events and spread information; conducting videotaped interviews with stakeholders; and putting on presentations. However, beyond Lave and Wenger’s description of learning in a community of practice, students’ change in participation within the Council occurs in a highly dynamic fashion. Students (both novices to the program and those who are more experienced) participate in literacy activities in multiple and shifting ways over time and at any given moment.

As learning occurs within the Council, our paper explores how identity development is not a simple progression from periphery to center. Students must inhabit a range of spaces whereby their status can differ dramatically. At one moment they may be presenting at a national conference, and at the next they may be students of a teacher who devalues them. Over time, however, this paper finds that an overall trend toward students gaining identities as researchers and change agents who do not only consume media, but produce it as well.

Authors