Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Border Crossing in Knowledge Production: Epistemological Pluralism, Ethical Globalism, and Agonistic Solidarities

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 9:45am, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Second Level, East Room 12

Abstract

This paper discusses the complexities of the political economy of academic knowledge production in transnational and transdisciplinary contexts and the challenges and opportunities of exploring the interface between local and global discourses and struggles against hegemonic systems.

Drawing on postcolonial, decolonial and indigenous theories, the idea of ‘epistemological pluralism’ (author, 2010; author, Ahenakew and Cooper 2011) is proposed as a transitional strategy to enable different knowledge systems to be held in productive tension, as opposed to being fused or framed in dialectical opposition to each other.

This paper explores issues related to methodological aspects of partnerships addressed in the theoretical literature.

It is argued that learning to navigate different epistemologies and to choose and perform aspects of those in different contexts can be a useful strategy for the emergence of ‘agonistic (Mouffe 2005) solidarities’ (Souza Santos 2007) and for addressing material and cultural inequalities. Becoming (consciously) bi- or multi- epistemic involves understanding different social/historical dynamic processes of knowledge construction, their limitations, as well as the social-historical relations of power that permeate knowledge production. It also involves being able to reference, combine and apply the appropriate frame of reference to an appropriate context. This negotiation can be conceptualised as ‘border crossing’ (Mignolo, 2002) in the interface between two or more knowledge systems. Royal (2007) refers to this process as “cross-disciplinary, cross-boundary thought, discussion and knowledge” (Royal, 2007, p.14).

Ethical border crossing demands attention to the political economy of knowledge production with an emphasis on social historical processes and the uneven value attributed to different knowledge systems historically. This paper aims to discuss how agendas defined in terms of reparation/recognition/redistribution and enacted in contexts of scarcity (i.e. competition for resources) often fail to produce ethical solidarities or alternatives to domination. The resulting forms of activism will tend to construct internal dissent as a pathology (projected back onto internal and external members of a community), breeding insecurity, anger, mistrust, self-righteousness, siege-consciousness and parochialism, which then lead to more trauma and its effects: more internalised oppression and more ethno (identity based)-stress. This paper suggests that epistemological pluralism, as a relational strategy, could support the quest for forms of activism and solidarities that cope with difference, dissensus, complexity, ambiguity, contingency and uncertainty and are based on something other than anger or guilt.

References:

Author, Cash Ahenakew, and Garrick Cooper. (2011). “Epistemological pluralism: challenges for higher education,” Alternative Journal, 7(1):40-50.

Author (2010). “Global education in the ‘21st century’: Two different perspectives on the ‘post-’ of postmodernism,” International Journal of Development Education and Global Learning 2(2): 5–22.

Mignolo, Walter. (2002). “The enduring enchantment”, South Atlantic Quarterly 101(4): 927-954

Mouffe, Chantal. (2005). On the political. Abindgon and New York: Routledge.
Souza Santos, Boaventura. (2007). Beyond abyssal thinking: From global lines to ecologies of knowledges. Eurozine. Available at www.eurozine.com/articles/2007-06-29-santos-en.html (accessed February 27, 2011).

Spivak, Gayatri. (1994). “Bonding in difference.” In Another tongue: Nation and ethnicity in the linguistic borderlands edited by Alfred Arteaga (273–85). Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Author