Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teacher Epistemologies of Comparing and Contrasting

Fri, April 13, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Fourth Level, North Port McNeill

Abstract

Making connections between math problems, concepts, and procedures is a core element of knowing and doing mathematics in an expert-like, flexible way (Polya, 1954; NCTM 2009; Kilpatrick et al, 2001). Many teachers do not capitalize on opportunities to help their students draw such connections, however (Hiebert et al, 2003; Richland, Zur & Holyoak, 2007). In order to better understand this disparity, the current study investigates preservice teachers’ epistemologies about the use of comparison and contrast in mathematics instruction. We were particularly interested to learn how preservice teachers’ early intuitions about comparisons align with techniques that have been shown to support students in drawing such connections.

Support strategies examined in the current study include reducing working memory demands on the learner by making connected content visible (Gick & Holyoak, 1983; Linn et al, 2006), reducing attentional demands by leaving these visible simultaneously (Cho, Holyoak & Cannon, 2007; Richland & McDonough, 2010; Rittle-Johnson & Star, 2007), and using linking gestures (Alibali & Nathan, 2007; Goldin-Meadow, 2003).

In the current study, eighty preservice teachers from a University of California MAT teacher credential program were videotaped teaching a portion of an algebra lesson. They were provided with a problem and two student solutions they were told had been produced within their classroom lesson - one solution was correct, and one was a misconception. The teachers were only given the direction to teach this content in any way of their choice. They were not instructed regarding whether to use or compare the multiple student solutions. These stimuli were taken from the measure of mathematical knowledge for teaching of algebra (Hill, Schilling, & Ball, 2004). This instrument serves as an excellent prompt for diagnosing teacher thinking.

Lesson videotapes were then coded to identify teacher use of contrasting cases, including whether the teacher addressed the two contrasting student solutions at all, if so, whether the teacher made an explicit contrast between them, whether the teacher made the solutions visible, whether the teacher made them visible simultaneously, and whether they used linking gestures. Overall, the data revealed that almost half of the preservice teachers (49%) did not make any attempt to compare or contrast the two solution strategies hypothetically produced within their classroom nor compared the main problem to a second problem. Those that did were still not likely to use the additional support strategies. Of six different support strategies that were coded, participants used at most three. Only 28% showed both solution strategies simultaneously, and 32% used linking gestures. We conclude that pre-service teachers are not entering the classroom with an intuitive orientation toward using contrasting cases. Additionally, these teachers rarely provided adequate support to ensure that their students would have benefited from the comparison opportunity. Instructional practices are typically deeply engrained in teachers’ belief epistemologies and thereby are very difficult to change (Stigler & Hiebert, 1999). Thus, research on comparison and contrasting cases must be explicitly and thoughtfully integrated into professional development to enable the growing literature in this field to impact teacher practice.

Authors