Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Gamelan Project: A Study of Synchrony and Attention

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 10:15am, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Grand Ballroom Level, North Grand Ballroom B

Abstract

Synchrony—the coordinated processing of time—is an often-overlooked, yet critical context for human interaction. The ability to synchronize underlies all face to face interpersonal communication. Thus, impaired or refined ability at synchrony may ultimately have a strong impact on learning. Group music practice—being ubiquitous in human culture and demanding synchrony across multiple nested timescales—is uniquely suited not only for study of temporal processing but also as a possible intervention for its refinement. The gamelan project, named for the Balinese musical genre that highly values synchrony, was initiated at the Temporal Dynamics of Learning Center to explore this possibility.

Ethnomusicologist and music teacher Alexander Khalil observed that children in his classroom who synchronized poorly in a group music setting tended to also suffer attention deficits. Impaired temporal processing, manifest in poor ability at duration discrimination, production, or increased variability in rhythmic tapping, has been reported in a number of studies of ADHD populations.

The first phase of the gamelan project confirmed Khalil’s observations. Using gamelan-like instruments fitted with piezoelectric sensors, we measured the ability of 85 elementary school children to synchronize to a driving beat in a group setting. We correlated this measure against psychometric tests for attention and teacher ratings on the Swan scale of attention. A significant correlation was found across all measures with all correlations being above 0.28 and all p-values below 0.005. Although this correlation establishes that the ability to synchronize is related to attentional performance, a central question remains: is ability at synchrony merely predictive of attentional performance—perhaps due to attentional allocation—or can improved synchrony through group music practice drive improvements in attentional performance that will translate to improved learning?

The present study addresses this question in two ways. First, through a pre- post intervention paradigm we compare changes on psychometric measures of attention, parent and teacher questionnaires, with improvements at ability in synchrony in study groups receiving an ensemble music training and controls. Second, we compare neurophysiological differences in response to auditory stimuli with ability to synchronize, and attentional performance in clinical and neurotypical populations.

The possibility that group music practice may fine tune ability at synchrony opens a window of opportunity for fine- tuning basic processing in children with deficits in these areas. This fine- tuning may lead to improvements in cognitive abilities necessary for effective school performance and learning in a social setting.

Author