Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Student Learning Plans (SLPs): A Review of State Policies and Research on Effectiveness
Perspective & Significance
Some educators and education stakeholders have promoted SLPs as a reform strategy to personalize the learning environment for nearly twenty years. More recently, state policymakers are looking at SLPs as a strategy to address gaps in students’ college and career readiness. Increasingly, states are passing legislation to require SLPs as part of efforts to strengthen high school graduation requirements and align those requirements to new college- and career-ready standards. Currently, nearly half of all states nationwide require students to develop career-focused learning plans during their middle and high school years.
Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to provide state policymakers with a better understanding of what student learning plans are as well as how and to what extent their use is mandated in other states. The paper describes current state trends in mandating SLPs and an overview of the research on the effectiveness of SLPs on improving a variety of student outcomes.
Methods
The paper is based on a review of recent literature and research on SLPs, and a state-by-state review of state education agency websites and state statutes to identify regulatory trends in mandating that students develop SLPs.
Findings
Twenty-three states plus the District of Columbia require that students develop learning plans. Of these, eighteen states have laws within their statutes that mandate the development of learning plans, while the other five require SLPs through regulation. Many states have learning plan requirements for certain subsets of their student body. A number of states, including Colorado and Kansas, mandate that all gifted and talented students have a learning plan, while other states, such as California and North Dakota, mandate that all English-language learners have a learning plan to guide their academic progress. Moreover, many states, including Massachusetts and Texas have some requirement for the development of learning plans for students who are considered “off-track” academically.
While there is considerable variation in how states have implemented learning plans, SLPs share a number of common characteristics across states that have adopted them. SLPs are developed collaboratively by students, parents and school staff, and generally focus on three goals: academic, career and personal. As part of the planning process, there is typically an opportunity for students to assess and document their skills and interests. Many utilize portfolios to document students’ academic, extra-curricular, work and personal experiences and achievements. All states that require SLPs require that plans are updated at regular intervals.
Our review of recent research found that the empirical evidence on the effectiveness of SLPs in improving academic achievement, graduation rates, or persistence in postsecondary education or work is limited. However, there is a growing body of research on the impact of SLPs on other student outcomes, such as motivation and engagement, goal setting, long-term planning, increased awareness of career options, and parental involvement in academic and career decisions.