Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Educating youth to be/become citizens who will embody and enact the civic values of democracy within the various spheres of society emerged as topic of intense debate throughout Spain with the introduction of a new civics education course. Democracy, citizenship and identity are delicate issues within a Spain rattled by a painful past with totalitarianism and a Catalonia whose own democracy and fragile sense of nationhood has developed within a context of struggle against the political dominance of the central Spanish state. This deep-running historical memory, alongside globalization and transnational migrations that challenge the boundaries of national belonging and citizenship, renders the project of forming citizens all the more complex. Defining terms such as democracy and citizenship within a social field cross cut by ideological fault lines and tilled by a contested history are fraught with tension as the question inevitably turns to: Whose version and vision of citizenship and democracy?
Drawing on findings for a yearlong ethnographic study in a secondary school in Catalonia, this paper explores the tensions and contradictions of learning citizenship identities for immigrant youth (from Morocco and Latin America) in a citizenship education class. I aim to trace the complex ways in which broader discourses of the normative citizen were (re)produced and negotiated in everyday interactions and relations between differently positioned actors within the classroom (peer relations/teacher-student relations). Framing the citizenship education classroom as a site of cultural politics, this paper examines these more subtle exclusionary processes and how immigrant youth maneuvered amidst these dynamics.
This paper finds that the citizenship education classroom, in the absence of an engaged and critical analysis of the gendered-, raced-, class- and “culture”- based assumptions informing definitions of citizenship and democracy, communicates powerful lessons to students about the politics of belonging—vesting some with more dominating power and relegating others to more marginal forms of belonging. Rather than cultivating in immigrant students a resilient sense of social belonging, as one of its stated aims, it can communicate to youth lasting lessons about their inherent non-belonging. The room for maneuver made available for immigrant students that do not fit the dominant definitions of “the democratic citizen” is at once a troubling and hopeful question that I believe to be at the heart of rethinking civics education as critical practice within democratic societies.