Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Doing Reading: Student Understandings of What It Means to Read in Dialogically and Monologically Organized Classrooms

Sat, April 14, 8:15 to 9:45am, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Third Level, South Beluga

Abstract

While classroom “discussion” aimed at fostering text comprehension may be ubiquitous, research has identified considerable differences in what discussion means, and how these differences play out in reading achievement. There is evidence that students perform better on achievement measures in classrooms where students are positioned in more generative, agentive roles vis-à-vis textual meaning (dialogic instruction) than in classrooms where students are positioned as recipients of knowledge about textual meaning (monologic instruction) (Nystrand, 1997).
Freebody, Luke, & Gilbert (1991) have suggested, however, that focusing simply on achievement measures may cause us to overlook the larger socializing work that such practices may accomplish: “The crucial matter for teachers is not to determine how best to teach reading, but rather to scrutinize the various reading practices and positions that are interactively built and privileged in the classroom by particular instructional activities” (p. 438). In other words, what does reading become for students as they participate in various classroom text discussion practices?
Our study examined students’ understanding of what it means to read in monologic and dialogic classroom environments through a comparative investigation of two contrasting second grade bilingual classrooms. We traced teacher language, student participation in discussions, and student understandings of the meaning of reading across a full academic year in each classroom. Data sources included transcripts of discussions of 18 texts and 80 student interviews.
After coding each classroom’s instructional discourse for dialogic talk moves during reading discussions (cf. Nystrand, 1997) to identify and verify differences, we then asked: within each classroom, a) how did students participate in reading during whole-group and small-group discussions of text? b) how did students describe their actions during reading discussions? and c) how did students describe the ways in which they engaged in reading and their reasons behind these actions? Finally, we asked: to what extent and how were students’ participation, reasoning, and perspectives mediated by the discursive practices of each teacher? We relied on grounded theory (Strauss & Corbin, 1998) to develop codes that described students’ discursive moves (e.g., contesting another student’s textual interpretation) as well as thematic patterns (e.g., reading as important for test-taking).
We found considerable differences in the instruction as well as in a) beliefs about what constituted “good” reading; b) which aspects of text were discussed, and how these discussions proceeded; c) the public visibility of multiple possible interpretations of text; and d) the extent to which students functioned as resources for each other’s textual understandings. Our findings suggest that, in monologically organized classrooms, reading is principally enacted as a set of procedures, with children identifying reading practices as fundamentally about correct answers, testing, and future schooling; while, in dialogically organized classrooms, reading is considered a social negotiation of meaning in which multiple perspectives on text emerge. We propose that students’ understandings of what it means to read are intricately connected with the discursive organization of the classroom, and argue that dialogically organized discussions play a crucial role in supporting students’ understandings of reading as an active process of negotiating meaning.

Authors