Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Catholic School Administrators’ Attitudes Toward Diversity

Sun, April 15, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Pan Pacific, Floor: Lobby Level, Crystal Pavilion C

Abstract

Catholic schools have grown increasingly diverse in past decades. According to the National Catholic Educational Association (2011), the minority population of Catholic schools has grown from 10.8% in 1970 to 30.3% in 2011. Throughout this time, several research studies have examined the academic achievement of white and minority students in Catholic schools (Coleman, Hoffer, and Kilgore, 1982; Hoffer, 1998; Carbonaro, 2006; Carbonaro and Covay, 2010). These studies have sought to determine if Catholic schools better represent the “common school” ideal than public schools by generating more similar academic outcomes for students across racial and ethnic groups. While findings are mixed regarding the ability of Catholic schools to effectively reduce achievement gaps, the research agenda has led to an examination of the social environment in Catholic schools to supplement and clarify researchers’ understanding of academic outcomes for diverse students (Coleman and Hoffer, 1987; Bryk, Lee, and Holland, 1993). The existing research has not, however, directly addressed attitudes toward diversity in Catholic schools. As the minority population in the schools grows, an understanding of school employees’ sentiments regarding diversity will be particularly important because their attitudes can alter the social and academic environments.

The research described here seeks to supplement the existing work by providing a qualitative analysis of Catholic school administrators’ attitudes toward diversity. The data utilized for the report were gathered from administrators in a geographic area that recently implemented a school voucher program. Voucher initiatives provide a natural experiment for examining attitudes toward diversity because they encourage more families to consider Catholic education as an affordable alternative to public schools, which often increases racial and ethnic diversity as well as religious and socioeconomic diversity. In the subject diocese, the recent commencement of the program and subsequent changes in school populations increase the salience of diversity topics for the administrators.

The data indicate that administrators can broadly be categorized into two areas of focus – mission or market. Mission-focused administrators embrace vouchers as a method for invigorating Catholic schools and explicitly welcome minority students. They express a desire to provide a Catholic education to all interested students and rarely discuss concerns regarding the impact of students’ backgrounds on academic outcomes, instead focusing on the need to access resources to provide high-quality academic programs. Market-focused administrators are concerned about the possible negative impacts of voucher students on academic outcomes and the Catholic nature of their schools. Although they do not explicitly object to voucher students on the basis of their race or ethnicity, they do cite background characteristics often associated with minority students, such as poverty and single-family homes, as detrimental to the school’s success. They view the group of students receiving vouchers as a destabilizing force that could counterintuitively reduce enrollment at schools by making them less attractive to non-voucher families. The results suggest that as Catholic schools continue to diversify and voucher programs become more common, administrators’ differing attitudes toward diversity will become increasingly important in shaping Catholic schools’ social environments and, indirectly, students’ academic outcomes.

Author