Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Literacy as Social Movement: Critical Civic Pedagogy in Urban High School English Classrooms

Mon, April 16, 4:05 to 5:35pm, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Third Level, South Pavilion Ballroom B

Abstract

Levels of civic engagement and literacy proficiency among students of color and low-income students lag behind those of their more affluent, white peers. Data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) civics test shows that at all tested grade levels, low-income and minority students earn lower scores than middle-class and white students (Lutkus, 1999). In terms of literacy, the American College Testing (ACT) program reveals that low-income and minority students are up to two and a half times less likely to be prepared for college-level reading (ACT, 2005).

Scholars agree that schools have contributed to these disparities and have a crucial role to play in reversing them (Kahne & Middagh, 2008; Fine et al, 2004). Unfortunately, mainstream curriculum, pedagogy, and policy in the fields of civic and literacy education have continued to operate in near total isolation and without any regard for the unequal social and political context in which they are situated (Gutierrez, 2010). What is missing from the discourse in both fields is a more fully articulated, interdisciplinary understanding of the connected meanings of citizenship and literacy in a 21st century world still structured by inequality.

This paper contributes to this understanding by exploring the unique role that urban high school English classrooms play as sites of critical civic learning. It analyzes how critical pedagogical practices in the area of literacy provide students of color with empowering and critical civic learning opportunities. This paper presents findings from pedagogical case studies of three powerful high school English classrooms, as well as results from a nationwide survey of high school English teachers. Findings are drawn from analysis of field notes, teacher and student interviews, survey data, student work, and teacher inquiry groups.

This paper aims to put progressive theories of democracy, literacy, and classroom pedagogy into productive conversation with each other in order to frame new critical classroom research. Critical literacy provides a theoretical framework that acknowledges the connection between citizenship, literacy, and a context of systemic inequality. Theorists argue that in order for literacy to become meaningful, it must be conceived as a form of cultural production and a crucial way in which people create and transform meanings about our world (Freire & Macedo, 1987; Street, 1984). This perspective takes seriously the necessity for literacy to relate to the promotion of social justice and focuses on literacy as a means of political empowerment for oppressed populations, linking the reading of the word to a reading of the world (Morrell, 2008; Freire, 1987; Barton, Hamilton & Ivancic, 2000).

In this work, I find that the pedagogy enacted by individual English teachers plays a crucial role how their classrooms embody democratic communities of practice and challenge. Teachers’ literate and civic identities, as well as their beliefs about race and systemic inequality, all have an important influence on the practices that they introduce to their students. In turn, the practices that they implement have the power to create transformative learning experiences that embody decolonizing and empowering praxis for urban students.

Author