Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This paper draws on pioneering work by psychotherapists and educators, who elicit artistic expressions in order to understand children’s knowledge and experience. Analyzing children’s art thus allows professionals to evaluate learning (Dorn, et. al., 2004) or diagnose family dysfunction (Malchiodi, 1998). I argue that artistic expression is also a pedagogical and evaluative tool for STEM learning. In early formative evaluations for interactive mixed reality museum exhibits, I elicited artwork from middle-school children. Depicting humans’ relationships with STEM concepts and products, these artworks suggest ways to use formative evaluation to proactively—rather than reactively—shape workable solutions to complex human challenges.
Evaluation 1. To assess knowledge about water, 15 sixth-graders sketched water’s impact on (1) themselves and their families, and (2) their region and the world. The sketches displayed their knowledge about existing conditions. The goal for the session was met: the students confirmed their understanding of challenges (pollution, conservation) and concepts (hydrological cycle, hygiene). However, few concrete solutions emerged. Some respondents portrayed themselves as potential stewards or activists at the local level, conserving water at home, for example. But their global visions—often idealized, sometimes highly abstracted “god views”—indicated that few saw themselves as part of a larger solution.
Evaluation 2. To elicit designs for technologies of the future, 50 children drew their projections of vehicles, homes, or clothing, wrote scripts describing specific elements of their drawings, and then animated their creations in a program called SketchNTell. The prompts elicited solutions rather than status quo; scripting afforded time for reflection (What fuel should I use? How might the dashboard function? What properties allow fabric to be worn in space?). Revising their images led them to depict themselves using the products or alter aspects of the technology (e.g., adjusting a hovercraft’s exhaust flames to minimize damage).
Their drawings, in short, captured human agents actively engaged in conservation, usability, ethical use, recycling, repurposing. And, I would argue, drawing, reflection, and revision afforded them a measure of human agency.
Evaluation 3. The next round of formative evaluation studies will further afford agency by engaging participants in 3D modeling. Participants will download a basic modeling package and create innovative designs in response to specific, carefully constructed project scenarios. Participants will thereby move beyond simple description and knowledge display to reflectively developing and testing innovative solutions to technological challenges (Manovich, 2006). Formative evaluation will vet the download for usability and refine the scenarios’ engagement value. Then, the package will be offered to virtual world visitors so they can learn and practice STEM skills (3D modeling) and habits of mind (planning, prototyping, reflecting, refining, and presenting their solutions).
This series of evaluations began with the commonplace finding that adolescents influence their families’ technology purchases (Prensky, 2001) and leisure learning activities (Hooper-Greenhill 1991; Falk & Dierking, 2000) and teach themselves and others to use technologies (Prensky, 2001). Passive learning and knowledge demonstration responses gave way to a more actively pedagogical and reflective type of evaluation that amplified personal agency. Both evaluators and participants became active learners.