Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Student Perceptions Working Group

Sat, April 14, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott Pinnacle, Floor: Third Level, Pinnacle II

Abstract

Using student survey responses, this group has measured multiple dimensions of teacher effectiveness in each participating classroom. In contrast with observations by supervisors, which are time consuming and may not represent normal classroom conditions, student surveys can be done quickly across large numbers of classrooms. In addition, students can respond concerning what most typically transpires—when there are no visitors in the classroom. Our initial analysis (METproject Research Paper, 2010) indicated that survey-based indicators can be reliable predictors of student achievement gains. This initial finding suggests that student surveys might become relatively low-cost alternatives for assessing the quality of instruction across large numbers of classrooms.
This presentation extends the initial analysis by examining how the results differ across varying student and teacher demographic and performance characteristics. New statistical and psychometric analysis of the existing data will inform decisions concerning which items are most predictive of student learning gains under which conditions.
The framework underlying the surveys draws upon several literatures. In addition to research on classroom instruction, these include business marketing, social work, innovation diffusion, educational psychology, child development and group-process.
The basic idea is that (A) adult and school organizational norms influence (B) classroom conditions, which influence (C) student engagement which, in turn, influences (D) student achievement. The central focus concerning student responses to effective instruction is on achieving the following five student engagement targets: (1) Begin the semester feeling trustful of the teacher and interested (instead of mistrustful and uninterested); (2) Experience a good balance between teacher control and student autonomy (instead of too little or too much of either); (3) Be ambitiously goal-oriented toward mastering lessons (instead of feeling ambivalent); and (4) Work industriously in pursuing academic goals (instead of becoming discouraged in the face of difficulty or disengaged due to boredom). (5) Achieve increased competence and a greater sense of efficacy, having become better prepared for future schooling and life experiences.
Five categories of classroom conditions promote the above forms of engagement. (1) Feasibility: Instruction (e.g., a teacher with multiple good ways of explaining key concepts) and supports (e.g., assistance outside the classroom) help students believe that success is possible. (2) Relevance: Lessons respond to students’ curiosities, relate to their lived experiences, have clear purposes and are related to future pursuits. (3) Enjoyment: Lessons are interesting, stimulating and appropriately challenging. (4) Teacher Support and Press: Teachers are encouraging and supportive, but also press students to work hard, think rigorously and behave cooperatively. (5) Peer Support: Peers are supportive of one another (or at least do not interfere with one another’s success).

Author