Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Educational Innovation and the “Appropriation” of the Ideals of “New” Education: Primary Education in Belgium in the 1930s

Sat, April 14, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: First Level, West Room 114&115

Abstract

It is apparent from the existing research that since the end of the 18th Century, a number of tenacious basic mechanisms have been at work in the field of education – mechanisms that may be viewed as rules underpinning educational behavior. Larry Cuban is one of the authors who have most successfully demonstrated the immense stability of classroom activities. In this respect he has used the notion “grammar of schooling”, which occupies a central place in our theoretical part, although we have interpreted it somewhat more broadly. The often unwritten, though nevertheless fairly well established rules of school life, which changed educational reforms rather than that educational reforms were capable of changing schools, could not be separated in our view from the underlying “pedagogical semantics” (detected in the German research concerning the phenomenon of Pädagogisierung, i.e. “educationalization). One of the outcomes of these basic structural processes that seem to govern the educational practices is that attempts of renewal inevitably have to run against a wall of firmly established habits.
That this gap between proposed innovations and everyday classroom experiences proved ultimately to be much more than simply a historical irony was plain from our studies carried out into Belgium’s 1936 Curriculum Reform. There is clearly a constant tension between the history of educational ideas context in which the educational reform is rooted and the frequently conservative educational historical context in which they have to be implemented. Innovations, such as the introduction of a new curriculum, seem to clash with the virtual immutability of classroom practice. However, in spite of the inertia of teaching behavior, this does not mean that nothing changes. On the contrary, in our view the pedagogical reform ideals are “appropriated” until they fit into the frameworks of the existing grammars of schooling and educationalization.
In our presentation we will further illustrate this phenomenon on the basis of some Belgian educational films from the 1930s. On the one hand we will use some fragments of the propaganda of the Decroly schools, explaining the New Education ideals that were behind the 1936 reform. On the other hand we will have a look at a “didactic” film on arithmetic and reading methods in a municipal school (Mortsel near Antwerp) sponsored by Gevaert company. Our main conclusion will be that the “new” did not involve a radical break with modernizing trends from which itself had emerged and that it wanted to combat. Apart from the general value of such historical insights – e.g. one may not expect that every single reform will be implemented as it was prescribed – the paper shows how concrete instruction methods have been able to survive in history.

Author