Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Conceptual and Theoretical Underpinnings of Case Analysis

Fri, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Third Level, Cook

Abstract

Classroom cases are authentic situations that are contextually rich and highly memorable for learners (Bonk & Zhang, 2008). Cases activate learner characteristics such as being active, self-directed, collaborative, reflective and critical which contribute to meaningful learning (Jonassen, Howland, Marra, & Crismond, 2007). Cases are natural and powerful formalism for storying and describing experiential knowledge that is essential to problem solving (Jonassen & Hernandez-Serrano, 2002). CBL is an instructional design process that is inquiry oriented, self-directed and collaborative especially in the analysis of specific real-life situations where multiple perspectives are called for. It is an effective learning approach because it bridges the gap between theory and practice (Flynn & Klein, 2001). Choi and Lee (2008) reported that CBL facilitates the learners’ application of knowledge in real world problem solving, in particular in the CM cases. According to Bennett (2010), case analysis tasks that the learners are engaged in during CBL have the potential to increase their awareness, improve discussion and reflection that help them form their mental pictures.

Case analysis was found to help teachers develop expertise and professionalism. Through case analysis, they become more aware of their experiences which in turn help to build their sense of professional identity (Harrington, Quinn-Leering, & Hodson, 1996). Case analysis helped teachers model the experts’ footsteps in interpreting issues, making decisions and conceptualizing action plans, which allow them to initiate their transition to the teaching community (Kim & Hannafin, 2009). Case analysis is problem solving that makes use of learners’ higher order thinking skills. Through case discussions, learners play active roles in asking questions, piecing the evidence from the information presented and discussing with peers. It also requires critical analysis such as generating and comparing ideas and decision-making on the part of the learners. However, case analysis poses two levels of challenges. At the facilitator level, they face challenges in scaffolding learners for case analysis which is a cognitively demanding process. As a result, oversights by the facilitators could be due to any of the following:
• Focusing on outcomes rather than process
• Lack asking probing questions to get into in-depth discussion of possible solutions
• Assume learners have the knowledge and skills to analyse cases
• Without directing learners to the principles and theories of the topic
• Giving insufficient time for learners’ reflection and refinement of proposed solutions

Similarly, challenges faced by learners could be due to the following:
• Treat a case in an indifferent manner, trivializing the content
• Work out quick fix and superficial solutions
• Lack critical reading and thinking skills
• Propose solutions without checking with principles and theories of the topic

For this session, we will focus on the challenges faced by the BTs (the learners) and look at how a structured approach of case analysis can help them to learn better and avoid the pitfalls mentioned above. Before learning how to engage in case analysis, we need to know more about the characteristics of classroom cases which will be elaborated in paper 2.

Author