Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Using Collaborative Multimodal Analysis in Dramatic Inquiry Pedagogy to Make Research Agentic, Dialogic, and Inclusive

Mon, April 20, 8:15 to 9:45am, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Lincolnshire

Abstract

Overview/Purpose: We explore how collaborative multimodal analysis, in participatory action research by university researchers and a high school English teacher using dramatic inquiry pedagogy, made visible what had previously been un-seen: how participants’ agency was affected by social positioning in real and imagined activities and contexts. Additionally, we show how the analysis mediated the teacher paying more attention to how her teaching affected student agency in two ways. First, designing activities and positioning students in both real and imagined contexts in ways intended to support more dialogic and more inclusive meaning-making among all participants. Second, interrupting social interactions and practices by herself and students that seemed to privilege the participation of some students while monologically excluding those of others.

Theoretical Perspectives:
This presentation assumes literacy is learned in multimodal (Jewitt & Kress, 2003; Albers & Sanders, 2010) cultural historical activities (Roth & Lee, 2007) and takes a sociocultural view of literacy research with attention to agency, power, and identity (Lewis, Enciso, & Moje, 2007), social positioning (Harre & Langenhove, 1999), and dialogic inquiry (Wells, 1998; Stein, 2007; Ryan et al, 2010) with increased affordances possible in dramatic pedagogy (Heathcote, 1984; Franks, 2003; Author5 2011; 2014).

Data Sources/Methods: We draw from data gathered in a one-year collaborative action research study of English teaching using dramatic inquiry in a 12th grade classroom of six students at a school for blind/visually-impaired students. We present examples of individual and collaborative multimodal analysis of data extracts from sequenced videotaped one-hour sessions exploring an Edgar Allan Poe short story. Students in collaboration with their teacher had read text extracts as if they were haunted house designers of a specially commissioned interactive museum in a refurbished period house intended to introduce visitors to themes, events, and characters. Multimodal activities included dialogue and/or reading and/or writing (sometimes using specialized technology) in whole/small groups mediated by material objects, tactile representations, model-making, and social embodied movement as if designers in the museum under construction.

In addition to field notes and digital photographs of students’ artifacts and writing, video data sources include: teaching sessions, teacher and student reflections. Following Norris (2004), analysis focused on modal density and each student’s foreground, mid-ground, and background attention in relation to real and imagined actions, objects, and other people. Following Alexander (2006) and Author5 (2014), analysis was coded, clustered, and compared using criteria for dialogic talk in relation both to each person present and the real and imagined contexts.

Findings:
We show how multimodal analysis by researchers and teacher made previously un-seen effects of social positioning on student agency in real and imagined activities and contexts more visible leading the teacher to change her practice.

Significance: We need to understand more about the possibilities and challenges of researching teaching multimodal literacies mediated by collaborative inclusive, dialogic meaning-making possible in the embodied and fictionalized contexts of dramatic inquiry.
 

Authors