Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper takes a cultural studies approach to trace the figure of the trans child across different media representations. As the subjects of Dateline and 20/20 specials, multiple online articles and (“mommy”) blogs, and a new documentary, I wish to narrate ‘the story so far’ of the figure of the trans child. My intention is look at the popular reception of trans and gender non-conforming children as constructing a story that inevitably becomes a universalizing narrative through which we read all gender non-conforming childhoods. The purpose is to consider and complicate the framing of trans children under the liberal banner of ‘born this way’ that reinforces mainstream LGBT culture and also reproduces transgender children as “martyr-target-victim” (Rofes, 2004). I do not try to infer the way of life of young trans children from the popular representations of trans children since media stories flatten out the important differences of race, class, and sexuality that children experience in various ways. Rather, I suggest that the recent coverage speaks to our framing of trans children and our educational approaches and policies that are meant to affirm and/or protect gender non-conforming children. The socializing mechanisms of schooling typically do not teach young people how to be gay or trans (Sedgwick, 1991). This makes an analysis of media representations a special vantage point to consider how we learn about trans children from the stories we see on TV and online. Their trans identity before adulthood causes great anxiety among conservative and liberal ideologies, as social identities are typically thought of as unavailable to children. Pre-pubescent trans children are considered too young to know what gender they want to be. In fact, the hesitation in allowing children to take hormone blockers hinges on the idea that because they are children they might change their minds about their gender. My particular interest is not about making available the normative LGBT identities to children as this dangerously slides into what Lisa Duggan (2003) calls homonormativity, or a politics that does not contest dominant gendered constructions but upholds and sustains them. For children, this is especially pronounced as we desexualize and re-orient LGBT identities as less threatening to maintain our fantasies of childhood innocence. My particular interest contends with the liberal educational attempts to protect and affirm the innocent trans child that may overlook the radical potential their performances and embodiments may hold. While Nancy Lesko (2001) critiques the discursive positioning of young people as always becoming, there may be something radically distinctive about the becoming-ness of children. My tracing of the figure of the trans child in our everyday thinking and educational imaginations serves as a launching pad to suggest “that preadult, preidentitarian [child] roles offer a set of opportunities for theorizing gender, sexuality, race, and social rebellion precisely because they occupy the space of the ‘not-yet’” (Halberstam, 2005, 177). My consideration of trans and gender non-conforming children is not to include them in our convictions toward certain educational framings—not to expand that frame but to re-fashion it altogether.