Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

"It Never Ends": How Asian American Female K–12 Teachers Experience Gender and Racial Microaggressions From Initial Licensure Preparation to Their Professional Careers

Sun, April 19, 4:05 to 6:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Lincolnshire

Abstract

This study investigated how 10 Asian American K-12 female public-school teachers in the upper Midwest experienced gender and racial microaggressions from their initial-licensure preparation to professional careers as classroom teachers. The findings will focus on two emergent themes: (a) incidents of racialized sexualization, and (b) racialized xenophobia. Recommendations address implications for teacher-preparation programs and K-12 schools.

Sue (2010) defines racial microaggressions as insults, putdowns, and slights from White Americans who usually “would consciously never discriminate” (p. xv) against people of color. Ultimately, microaggressions, while generally not intended to be offensive, in practice demeans people of color (Grier-Reed, 2010; Pittman, 2012; Sue, 2010). Recent studies have focused on how Asian Americans experience racial microaggressions, especially Asian American college students (e.g., Ong et al., 2013; Sue et al., 2007). Like other K-12 teachers of color, Asian American teachers experience multiple challenges working in public-school settings where conversations about race tend to be reactive and tense (Milner, 2010). Yet, as Asian Americans, the participants’ experiences are shaped by racially specific stereotypes including assumptions that they are foreigners and model minorities whose experiences are more like Whites than people of color (Sue et al., 2007, pp. 75-77).

Given the small number of Asian American teachers in the region, the snowball-sampling method was used to recruit participants from ethnically diverse subgroups. 10 teachers participated in this study. The following procedures were used to gather data: (a) distributing a demographic survey to gather baseline data, (b) interviewing participants for 60-90 minutes using semi-structured prompts focusing on different typologies of microaggressions (Sue, 2010), and (c) leading monthly focus groups lasting 2 hours each over a 6-month period. Finally, I am an Asian American faculty administrator employed at a private university in the upper Midwest, and was also a P-12 teacher in the 2000s. My intention is not to claim that I fully understand the experiences of the 10 teachers who participated in this study. Rather, I hope that my partial insights will help contextualize each participant’s experiences that revolve around raced experiences in the context of being a K-12 educator.

The findings will focus on three themes. First, the participants have differently and similarly coped with racial microaggressions in their preparation programs and professional lives. Verbal silence was the most commonly cited coping method while other mechanisms included directly confronting the perpetrator or using humor or sarcasm to respond to microaggressive comments. Second, despite their specific coping strategies, six participants (60%) stated that they eventually plan to leave the K-12 profession because they felt devalued, disrespected, and marginalized in their careers. The implications section pertains to both K-12 and teacher education with a focus on what Pollock (2008) describes as everyday anti-racism where institutions develop “an every day race consciousness” (p. xiii). The primary recommendation will focus on how schools and teacher-preparation programs could incorporate anti-racist strategies to tackle microaggressions to ultimately retain their teachers of color.

Author