Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The ubiquitous occurrence of boredom in education has sparked a growing interest in understanding its antecedents and effects (Acee et al., 2010; Daschmann, Goetz, & Stupnisky, 2011). According to the control-value theory (CVT) of academic emotions, boredom is hypothesized to occur when perceived value of the activity is low and perceived control over its outcomes is low (over-challenge) or high (under-challenge; Pekrun, Goetz, Daniels, Stupnisky, & Perry, 2010). The purpose of this research was to test these predictions on two components of boredom: (1) subjective experience of boredom and (2) momentary lapses in attention (or mind wandering), which is theorized to be an attentional correlate of boredom (Eastwood, Frischen, Fenske, & Smilek, 2012). We also tested the hypothesis that boredom and mind wandering mediate the relationship between perceptions of value and control and learning.
Data was collected from 187 undergraduate students in the US (mean age = 19.2 years; 57.2% female). Students spent an average of 32 minutes studying four texts on scientific research methods (e.g., causal claims, experimenter bias) of varying difficulty (related to control) and importance with respect to a subsequent achievement test (related to value). Students self-reported their perceptions of value, difficulty, as well as subjective boredom immediately after reading each of the four texts on 1 (low) to 6 (high) scales. Mind wandering was tracked via auditory thought probes that were pseudo-randomly placed throughout the texts. After studying all four texts, students completed a transfer test where they were asked to apply the core concepts to real-world research designs.
Data was analyzed with mixed-effects linear regression models with student as a random effect and text order and general topic interest as covariates. Consistent with CVT, perceived value was a significant (p < .05 unless specified otherwise) negative predictor of subjective boredom (B = -.22) while perceived difficulty was a positive predictor (B = .12). Similarly, perceived value (B = -.05) and difficulty (B = .08) were negative and positive predictors of mind wandering, respectively. Perceived value positively predicted performance on the transfer test (B = .09), but perceived difficulty did not. Finally, subjective boredom mediated the relationship between perceived value and transfer performance (low value → more boredom → lower transfer), but there was no mediation for mind wandering. None of the perceived value × difficulty interactions were significant.
In addition to confirming two key predictions of CVT (low value and low control → increased boredom), for the first time, these relationships were extended to overt lapses in attention (mind wandering), which is hypothesized to be a key attentional indicator of boredom. The study also provided evidence for the role of subjective boredom as a mediator between perceptions of value and transfer performance. The next step is to investigate how individual differences in prior knowledge and ability moderate the effect of perceived value and difficulty on boredom and learning.
Sidney K. D'Mello, University of Notre Dame
Caitlin Mills, University of Notre Dame
Arthur C. Graesser, The University of Memphis