Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Modeling the Processes of Diagramming Arguments That Support and Inhibit Students' Understanding of Complex Arguments

Fri, April 17, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Marriott, Floor: Fourth Level, Sheffield

Abstract

Research on the efficacy of diagramming complex arguments has been mixed. One reason for the mixed findings is that the precise processes students use to construct argument diagrams have yet to be fully examined. This study identified sequential patterns in argument diagramming actions performed by graduate-level students that created high versus low quality diagrams. Transitional state diagrams revealed patterns in the action sequences used by high vs. low performing students - processes believed to either help or inhibit students’ ability to construct accurate argument diagrams and achieve a better understanding of complex arguments. The findings reveal processes that can be embedded into future diagramming software to test how particular processes affect students’ analysis and understanding of complex arguments.

Authors