Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Exploring Virtue and Its Connection to Knowledge and Creativity

Mon, April 20, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Hyatt, Floor: East Tower - Gold Level, Columbus AB

Abstract

This presentation will explore ancient Greek and Chinese philosophy, as well as contemporary views that hold that there is a causal relationship between virtue, knowledge and creativity. This excursion works to inform current tenants of scientific thought that require objectivity as a foundation for inquiry and hold that human emotions, intentions or values must be minimized in the process of developing scientifically acceptable knowledge. According to the analysis proposed here the latter reflects a relatively new assumption that knowledge can be separated from the subjective. Prior to the modern era, subjectivity and knowledge were not seen as antithetical to one another. If virtue and its cultivation have a causal relationship with knowledge and creativity that is supported through contemplative practice, this has broad implications for educational theory and practice that will be explored in this presentation.
To explore the above idea I consider the philosophies and practices of the ancient Greeks and Daoists, as well as contemporary views on this topic. I draw on Hadot’s (1995) investigation of the Greek concept of development of virtue through care of the self and contemplative spiritual exercises as cultivating virtue by accessing cosmic consciousness. Similarly, I turn to Cleary (2003) who argued that the ancient Daoists linked the cultivation of virtue through contemplation with access to universal knowledge. Interestingly, a return to an integrated view of knowledge, soul and the good, is reflected in contemporary views on the nature of scientific knowledge as well. Einstein, the paragon of western science said, “There is no logical path to these laws (of the universe); only (through) intuition, resting on sympathetic understanding of experience can (we) reach them … The state of mind which enables a man to do work of this kind … is akin to that of the religious worshiper or the lover; the daily effort comes from no deliberate intention or program but straight from the heart” (quoted in Calaprice, 2011, p.364). Einstein also suggested a link between the soul, the good, and scientific inquiry, for the valuation of the good in life is a subjective exercise of the heart and the heart is supported by the rational capabilities of the mind (Calaprice, 2011, p. 322). Other, such as Kuhn (1970) spoke of scientists achieving intuitive leaps in the process of creating new scientific paradigms through intense work. Similarly Jahn & Dunne (2001) have observed that intention and emotional connection are factors in enabling intuition.
In the final section of this presentation, I reflect on the implications of such epistemology to contemporary educational practice. The recent contemplative turn in education may hold some promise in extending our epistemology to bind knowledge, creativity and virtue (Zajonc, 2006).

Author