Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Wisdom Behind Mindfulness-Based Curricular "Interventions"

Mon, April 20, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Hyatt, Floor: East Tower - Gold Level, Columbus AB

Abstract

While contemplative practices have emerged from wisdom-traditions, the rhetoric surrounding their justification in contemporary public educational settings has been substantially undergirded by the scientific evidence-based approach. Some suggest that this secularization and “scientification” of contemplative practices required for their acceptance within the public curriculum, bears a substantial risk of diluting these practices and distilling them from their ethical grounds (Rosch, 2006; Nelson, 2012). This presentation will propose that such critique should be acknowledged, however beyond the evidence based approach that tends to offer a rhetoric in which mindfulness is conceived as an instrumental “intervention”, lies a dramatic reconceptualization of education; one that may be in tune with core wisdom-traditions teachings.
From a historical perspective, science and wisdom traditions have been known as rivals however, a burgeoning contemplative turn in education (Eppert, 2013) proposes a novel situation in which the two can be interpreted to be involved in a mutual effort to provide a justification for contemplative practices in the curriculum. This presentation will propose that the practice and construct of “attention” can be interpreted as bridging between these two justificatory paths, and a vantage point from which we can re-examine what education is, and what makes for an educationally worthwhile activity (Peters, 1966). Reviewing “attention” from the perspective of wisdom traditions, contemplative neuroscience, and from the psychology of William James (1890) and Mihalyi Csikzentmihalyi (1990), this presentation proposes an educational typology that treats “attention” as a curricular deliberation point scaffolding the moment by moment experience of educational practice. It is suggested that the “deep teachings” of education precede content, and are grounded primarily in two meta-pedagogical orientations of attention that represent society’s ethos of where meaning is to be found: attend out there – know thy world (as most common in contemporary curriculum) and/or attend in here – know thyself (as many contemplative practices propose). The current contemplative turn in education re-enchants curriculum theory by postponing the question “what should students attend?” to ask firstly “where should students’ attention be oriented?”
The fundamental point that this analysis suggests is, that while we are busy preparing students for the job-market, teaching them various skills, and world-knowledge the primary teaching we give them is that their attention is required outside, and that education comprises of pedagogies that orient attention to world. A growing incorporation of mindfulness and other contemplative based “interventions” marks a dramatic change in our educational practice. Even if these interventions are proposed based as an economic-instrumental curricular device (e.g., enhancing performance, boosting academic achievements), they still drive home a novel teaching - Attending in is an educationally worthwhile activity. The primacy of performativity may still hold in educational practice, however, this novel contemplative turn may be inserting wisdom in to a public curriculum that is heavily grounded in a concern with informationalism.

Author