Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

On the Composition of Academic Work in Digital Times: An Atlas of Academic Practice

Fri, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre First Level, Zurich G

Abstract

The objectives of this study are focally aimed at deepening our understanding of the role of ‘the digital’ in contemporary academic practices. More precisely, this contribution investigates if and how both human and non-human (i.c. digital) actors are entangled together in the daily conduct of academic activities. The digital, in other words, is not considered as an explanatory factor driving some changes, but rather approached as a possibly constitutive element in enacting academic practice (Ruppert et al., 2013).

The conceptual framework combines sociomaterial with social topological approaches (e.g. Latour, 2005; Thompson & Cook, 2014). Both approaches are centrally concerned with how practices are taking up a certain form by means of (the relations between) human and non-human actors populating these practices. Hence, both approaches allow to describe the concrete composition of academic work. Core to both approaches is that they do not make particular assumptions regarding the role of ‘the digital’ in current academic work, or regarding the organization, function or meaning of this very work. Rather, this framework allows to focus analytically on actors, interactions and resulting assemblages of webs of relations between actors in order to describe academic practice.

In order to access academic practice, six purposefully sampled professors were interviewed. This was being done as accurately as possible, focusing on the concrete actors that took a part in particular activities and the relations that were established between these actors. Each interview was set up as a kind of hearing, where we asked each respondent to report on every detail of what s/he did the previous day (Nicolini, 2009). The resulting transcripts were considered as observer notes that present six accounts of academic practice and that were focused on the actors (both human and material) and interactions assembling on these six days.

In order to analyze the specific form of these academic practices, we composed network visualizations by means of the software program Gephi (www.gephi.org). This allowed for an analysis of the distribution of actors and the interactions between them, and eventually for investigating how agency is distributed and enacted within these webs of assembling actors and interactions (Fenwick & Edwards, 2010; Latour et al.; 2012. The constructed visualizations were treated as topological maps and grouped into three distinct profiles of academic practice, focusing on the relationality of (and between) different actors.

The results of this study will be presented as an atlas of different maps of academic practice. This atlas consists of visualizations of three profiles of academic practice and clearly shows the significant role that digital materials play in contemporary academic practices. In that respect, the atlas point to authorities, both human and material, that act as centers in the performing academic activities. It also points to boundary actors that associate different academic practices together and that as such might be considered to be prototypical academic objects. Third, the atlas allows to analyze the infrastructure of different academic practices, and to see to what extent this infrastructure is humanly, materially and/or digitally composed.

Authors