Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Diffusion Models in Singapore Schools: Dialectics of Centralization and Decentralization

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Lucerne Level, Lucerne I

Abstract

Objectives
This paper discusses a system’s model of diffusion of technologically mediated innovations in Singapore schools. We argue that centralized structures of the system can complement decentralized schools’ diffusion efforts. The research questions of the empirical studies that underlie this paper include: what are the different diffusion models (Clarke & Dede, 2009; Dede, 2006) in Singapore schools? What are the within- and cross-model enablers and inhibitors of diffusion? How can centralized structures support diffusion?

Theoretical Framework
By the early 70s, the main models of diffusion of innovation, particularly that of Rogers (2003), have been established (Meade & Islam, 2006). Such models describe the characteristics and process by which the innovation gets spread and adopted by others. Although, there has been research on bringing education innovations into the Singapore classrooms, there is little research on how innovations are diffused in its cultural-political context (Mishler, 1979) across classrooms. Scholars have tried to characterize the Singaporean educational context as a blend between centralization and decentralization (Author, 2014; Tan & Ng, 2007), and this paper makes a contribution by epitomizing the diffusion process from such a perspective.

Methods
The case study methodology (Yin, 2014) was adopted and research was carried out in two Future Schools in Singapore, as well as on three other innovations occurring in some schools across the nation. These purposively selected interventions gave us the sample from which to collect interview and observation data on the diffusion of innovation in Singapore schools. Interviews were conducted with school leaders and teachers. Ethnographic observations (Hammersley & Atkinson, 2007) were made of classroom teaching, as well as the interactions in professional learning communities.

Results
From the data collected, three models of diffusion are observed, which exist along a continuum. These models range from deep but narrow diffusion reach in a specific context at one end to non-deep but wide diffusion reach at the other end, with a variety of models that exhibit neither deep nor wide diffusion reach.

In order for the innovations to spread to other schools, it was found that a variety of within- and across-models factors were significant, for example, significant degrees of expert-teachers apprenticing novice-teachers; cross-schools’ leadership (Fullan 2014) and champions; augmentation of school resources from the community; capacity of school leaders and teachers; social capital (trust); as well as passion and belief in the innovation (Fullan & Langworthy, 2014).

Although Singapore schools are increasingly given to decentralization, yet the system has retained and created new centralized structures at the cluster and HQ levels which we found could be leveraged to spread innovation through the incentivization of school leaders and teachers to experiment with innovations and the like. That said, the centralization zeal to see the hasty propagation of innovations could be counter-productive as the capacity of teachers takes time to evolve. In such a scenario and others to be discussed, the delicate balance in centralization and decentralisation (Fullan, 1994; Wylie, 2008) for the diffusion of innovation could be thrown off and centralization could become an inhibiting factor.

Authors