Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Conditions That Enable Large-Scale Instructional Innovation in Mexican Public Middle Schools

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Lucerne Level, Lucerne I

Abstract

Objectives
This paper discusses the conditions under which instructional innovation can be disseminated on a large-scale by examining the Learning Community Project (LCP) in Mexico, an initially grassroots, NGO-led educational change initiative that succeeded in consolidating and disseminating a new pedagogy based on tutorial relationships from 8 to 6000 Mexican public schools between 2004 and 2012.

Perspective
The term instructional innovation is used herein to qualify pedagogical principles or practices that redefine the instructional core – the relationship between teacher and student in the presence of content (Cohen, Raudenbush & Ball, 2003). Large-scale instructional innovation is conceptualized as a process of wide-spread cultural change (Rochon, 1998) that occurs when new practices developed by a critical community are adopted and disseminated by movements in the social, political, and instructional arenas (Author, 2013).

Data Sources and Methods
Classroom observations in 8 schools from 4 school regions representing a broad range of implementation contexts were conducted to identify the tasks performed at the level of the instructional core (Doyle, 1983). Open ended, semi-structured interviews (Seidman, 2006) with a total of 24 LCP teachers, teacher coaches, and local educational authorities were used to capture the experiences of LCP actors and identify the conditions that enabled or constrained their efforts to incorporate and disseminate LCP’s core practice. The observed classroom practice was classified by level of sophistication (low, intermediate, and advanced), and examined against interview data to identify commonalities and differences among groups in different levels of practice, in terms of their experiences, knowledge, and access to enabling/constraining conditions.
Archival analysis (650 documents) and in-depth, semi-structured interviews with eight key LCP leaders were used to inquire about the origins and development of LCP and the wider social and political conditions that enabled or constrained the dissemination of tutorial networks across thousands of Mexican public schools.

Results
Key conditions identified as enablers for the dissemination of tutorial networks include:
a) Pedagogy that allows teachers to experience powerful learning and to witness observable improvements in the knowledge, skills and attitudes of their students as a result of changing their practice
b) Access to multiple opportunities to observe and practice the new pedagogy (e.g., classroom-based coaching, communities of practice, and school visits/exchanges);
c) Support or permission from local educational authorities to depart from conventional schooling practices
d) Small teacher to student ratio, multi-grade classrooms, and weaker presence of institutional controls over the everyday activities of schools in most of the historically marginalized communities where LCP first took root.
e) Guiding coalition of pedagogical change leaders with access to institutional power and political support to protect and expand the influence of the innovation

Scholarly Significance
The significance of this paper lies in its integration of three areas of the educational change field that have mostly been studied separately from each other, namely: instruction, educational innovation, and large-scale reform. The paper advances the development of explicit, practical theory that explains how and under what conditions effective instructional innovation can be brought to scale.

Author