Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objective
This study explores how underrepresented high school students’ science and racial/ethnic identities develop together through participation in the practices of science during summer science research programs. I ask two main questions:
• What are students’ incoming ideas about the practices of science and who can do science? How do students’ ideas shift following program participation?
• What types of instruction/pedagogy support holistic shifts in how youth of color see themselves in relation to science?
Theoretical Framework
I draw on socio-cultural theories of learning, identity and positioning (e.g. Harre, 2008, Holland et al.,1998, Wenger, 1998). Science identity literature offers insights into the types of identities offered to underrepresented youth (e.g. Polman & Miller, 2010; Tan & Calabrese Barton, 2010). While research shows that racial positioning matters for long-term science trajectories (e.g. Carlone & Johnson, 2007), treatments of race in relation to science are limited.
Scholars push for equitable approaches to science instruction that validate youths’ experiences and ways of knowing (e.g. Bang & Medin, 2010; Tan & Calabrese Barton 2007; Warren et al., 2001). Participation in authentic science experiences provides opportunities for students to construct unique epistemological stances (e.g. Sandoval, 2005) and identify as capable science learners (e.g. Lehrer, 2009). I utilize the “practice-linked identity” framework and its supporting identity constructing resources (Nasir & Cooks, 2009) in order to explore how learning, positioning and identities develop in context.
Methods/Data Sources
Programs. The three summer science programs involved in this study contrasted in two main ways: 1) program content: race/diversity explicit vs. race/diversity implicit, and 2) science investigation content: community-based or traditional (e.g. physics). Participants. 1) Students: grades 9-12, Northern California schools, 2) Mentors: science instructors/graduate students. Data Sources. 1) Pre/post student surveys; 2) Pre/post student content assessments; 3) Semi-structured interviews: a) student interviews (pre/post, 6 focal students/program), b) scientist mentors; 4) Program observations.
Results
Findings show that shifting ideas about what counts as science can help create shifts in students’ ideas about who can do science. Across all three programs, participation in authentic scientific research: 1) allowed students to add new practices to their repertories (e.g. presenting research), and 2) expanded or shifted the meanings students’ associated with scientific practices from traditional (e.g. prescribed, right/wrong) to authentic (e.g. iterative process). In addition, experiences with particular scientific practices (e.g. collecting data) shifted how students saw themselves in relation to science (e.g. increased perceived ability in science). However, findings indicate that in order to support holistic shifts in youth of colors’ ideas about who can do science, instruction/pedagogy that supports students’ science and racial identities is needed. Mentors that employed a racially/politically conscious lens made unique resources available that allowed youth of color to identify themselves/peers as scientists. Implications for school-based science instruction are discussed.
Significance
This research provides empirical evidence for the types of program resources that support holistic shifts in youth of colors’ ideas about what science is and who can do science. Findings can be applied to science classroom instruction to transform the teaching and learning of science in schools.