Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose
With the release of the Framework for K-12 Science Education (NRC, 2012) and the Next Generation Science Standards (NRC, 2013), learning science through engagement in epistemic practices has become a focus of instructional, curricular, and research efforts. We focus on scientific modeling as one example of an epistemic practice in the sciences. Research on modeling with K-12 students has focused on supporting students to use models that illuminate their thinking about disciplinary core ideas, as well as to develop explanations about phenomena (e.g., Windschitl, Thompson, & Braaten, 2008). Scientists also use models as predictive, and investigative tools, often as part of cutting edge research in their fields (cf. Giere, 2004). This paper highlights high school students engaging in modeling practices that mimic scientists’ use of these same practices.
Theoretical Framework
We grounded our analysis in a sociomaterial perspective on scientific practices (e.g., Latour, 1987; Pickering, 1995), meaning that students should be engaged in practices that mirror those of the specific disciplines in which they are working. We show an example of this using curricular materials that positioned youth as developing disciplinary experts (Harré et al., 2009; Paradise & Rogoff, 2009), capable of making meaningful epistemic contributions to the classroom, to scientific work, and to their communities. We examined students’ use of simulations using Giere’s framework describing scientists’ work of representing the world through modeling. Scientists do this by “exploiting similarities between a model and that aspect of the world it is being used to represent” (Giere, 2004, p. 747, emphasis in the original).
Methods
The data used in this analysis stems from a curricular unit titled, Predicting and Preventing Infectious Disease. During this unit, students engaged in global epidemic modeling to plan and carry out investigations that explored features of epidemics, infectious diseases, and human mobility as related to infectious disease. The data we analyzed for this study came from two classrooms and included: (a) video data (nine hours) of two focal groups, (b) student work, (c) our email communication with scientists, and (d) video recordings of student focus groups.
Results
Students engaged in investigations using models as their primary investigative tool. These investigations were supported by scientists who developed and actively used the models with which students engaged. Developing a model to run an epidemic simulation required students to make choices and claims about which components and values were most important to their investigation. Defining parameters required multi-disciplinary understanding of the disease and conditions that were being modeled. For example, one group chose to compare their simulation outputs with Centers for Disease Control data to better understand their own outputs. Students engaged in sophisticated dialogue with scientists about their modeling and the components and parameters involved in the work.
Scholarly significance
This analysis demonstrated that students’ modeling practices mimicked how models and simulations are used in the scientific disciplines as epistemic tools. We wish to dialogue with the field about what “counts” as epistemic engagement in scientific practices in K-12 science classrooms and why.