Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Protégés, Mentors, and Job Satisfaction: Faculty in Liberal Arts Colleges

Mon, April 20, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre First Level, Zurich F

Abstract

Objectives or Purposes: Mentoring is less universally available to faculty members as it is for those preparing to become faculty members. The research on faculty mentoring overwhelmingly focuses on research or medical settings and the early career stage. We know little about mentoring faculty in liberal arts settings or if mentoring programs might prepare the next generation of faculty leaders. This paper investigates who engages in mentoring and its relationship to job satisfaction, an important predictor of retention.

Perspective(s) or Theoretical Framework: This paper builds on prior work to develop a baseline understanding about faculty mentoring experiences (Thomas, Lunsford, & Rodrigues, 2013). It examines four critical questions about faculty mentoring characteristics and outcomes in liberal arts colleges. First, what are the demographic characteristics of faculty who engage in mentoring, including adjunct and part-time faculty? Second, how do these relationships develop and change? Third, can faculty engagement in mentoring relationships be associated with greater job satisfaction? Further, do high quality mentoring relationships have a greater effect on job satisfaction?

Methods, Techniques, or Modes of Inquiry: Analysis of data from the Initiative for Faculty Development in Liberal Arts Colleges answers these questions, and generated findings about the significance of individual characteristics on mentoring relationships, and the relationship between mentoring and job satisfaction across institutions and disciplines.

Data Source: A faculty development survey was administered to 2,492 faculty members of 13 liberal arts colleges. There were 541 completed surveys and 299 partially completed surveys. About half of the respondents (46%) were male or female (45%). Most respondents (35%) were at the professor rank, with 34% at the associate rank and 20% at the assistant rank; others were visiting or adjunct. Most respondents (34%) were from the natural sciences, followed by humanities (29%), social sciences (26%), and fine arts (7%).

Results and Conclusions: Results show mentoring occurs across ranks more than has been assumed and many faculty are simultaneously protégés and mentors. Sex, discipline and institution had no influence on participation in mentoring. About half of the faculty reported having at least one mentor in the last year with a modal response of two mentors. About 60 percent of faculty reported having at least one protégé in the last year. Protégés reported a higher quality relationship (Mean = 5.4 on a 1-7 scale) than did mentors (4.8 – 5.2 on a 1-7 scale). Job satisfaction was significantly predicted by having a mentor, rank, gender, and having a protégé, R2 = .13, F (4,372) = 13.5, p< .001.

Significance: This work provides knowledge about the nature, quality, and frequency of faculty mentoring within liberal arts colleges. It raises practice and policy questions. Should we expect faculty to seek out mentors or protégés? If not, how might institutions best support faculty who may not desire that kind of support? Attention may be warranted to support mentoring efforts across ranks, especially for part-time and adjunct faculty. Also, there may be an opportunity to educate faculty and administrators about the features of, and resources needed for, high quality relationships.

Author