Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Over the past decade, studies have emerged about the influence of administrators in upper elementary, middle, and high school classrooms yet there is a gap in the literature related to the impact of administrators in early childhood classrooms, particularly in settings serving Latino immigrant communities (Hammond, Muffs & Sciascia, 2001). Without much knowledge of ECE nor relationships with immigrant communities, administrators still affect the kinds of learning experiences teachers offer young children in early grade classrooms (Goldstein, 2005). This control can be damaging when coupled with low expectations and deficit beliefs about Latino immigrant families.
This paper discusses preliminary findings from a pilot study of administrators who work in districts and schools that serve a significant number of Latino immigrant families. The aim of this study has been to uncover how administrators describe high quality early childhood education and how they see the role of student agency specifically in the early learning experiences of young children of immigrants (see Adair, 2014). Using video-cued ethnography (Tobin, Hsueh & Karasawa, 2009) and qualitative interviewing, administrators including four principals, two superintendents and three-district curriculum directors were interviewed individually and in focus groups. Participants watched a video of a first grade classroom (serving mostly children from Latino and Latino immigrant families) in which children have a considerable amount of student agency. Children could choose topics in science to research. Children could choose where and what they read. Children could choose who they worked with. The administrators were asked to compare the classroom dynamics in the film with what they considered to be high-quality classrooms at their schools or in their districts. The film served as a stimulus for conversation and as a mechanism to compare ideas across cities. Participants’ answers were coded thematically and then comparatively both by administrative position and whether the administrator had immigrant experience and/or worked in rural, border or urban settings. By showing the same video to administrators, participants’ ideas about high quality early childhood education and student agency could be compared.
Preliminary findings suggest that there are disparities between what administrators described as high quality practices in early childhood classroom and their day-to-day expectations in the classrooms in their schools. Administrators also struggled to describe learning situations in which children could choose topics and make decisions for themselves and yet still have those classrooms orderly and “well-behaved.” Administrators also used deficit discourses to explain why certain communities or children were incapable of having such forms of agency or freedom in their classrooms.
These findings are meant to begin identifying obstacles that can prevent administrators from providing early learning experiences to all young children; Learning experiences that can develop higher level learning skills such as problem solving, decision-making, observation, critical thinking and project design. This paper will be presented by first showing a clip of the first grade film the administrators watched and then discussing the administrators’ reactions to the film as well as their opinions about what high quality early childhood looks like for young Latino children of immigrants.