Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Women and Moral Madness: When Increased Responsibility and Diminished Authority Meet

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, St. Gallen 2

Abstract

Teaching's feminized location affects all genders employed in this work, although in distinctive ways. When work is not work, teachers' articulations of moral claims question the very terms of a profession. Due to widespread expectations of teachers' submission and presumptions of their ineptitude that are not found in more masculine-oriented professions that carry similar responsibility, moral claims that pass judgment on the integrity of the profession and the ethics of pedagogical policy are too often cast by educational researchers and reformers as short-sighted, self-serving, and ultimately, remain unintelligible.

Problems of the unintelligibility of situated moral claims (in contrast to disinterested and “universal” moral perspective) and the lack of recognition of moral agency of women are concerns that have been taken up by feminist philosophers and cultural theorists. My philosophical analysis is interwoven with qualitative research drawn from two sets of interviews with current and former teachers from across the U.S. who experienced the implementation of large-scale educational reform. The first set of 13 interviews was conducted between 2006 and 2008. The second set of interviews is in progress. All of the teachers are currently working in public schools and have taught for at least 5 years, giving them perspective on Race to the Top initiatives including the adoption of the Common Core State Standards.

I will not be making a claim regarding the special moral capacities of women or teachers. Rather, utilizing philosophy and cultural theory, I trace the challenges teachers face in making their moral claims heard as moral. Failure to be recognized as moral agents could lead to what Kathryn Pauly Morgan calls "moral madness." In particular, as Barbara Houston explains, moral madness emerges most clearly when individuals are held responsible without being given commensurate authority to fulfill their responsibility, or more importantly, question the terms of responsibility. I show that teachers' failure to be heard as moral agents hinges on the feminized position of teaching that expects teachers to serve as moral exemplars while simultaneously stripping them of a moral voice and agency. Cassandra, the prophetess of Greek myth whose visions fail to be understood, provides an archetype of the feminine voice whose moral claims are unintelligible and the peril that ensues. This paper traces the discursive challenges teachers face when attempting to make their moral claims heard and shows what can be learned about the state of the profession when researchers and educational leaders heed their claims.

Author