Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In this paper we draw on research about collaborative models of teacher professional development (TPD) carried out in Brazil, Ireland and Sweden to explore the issue of voice and representation for all participants of the collaborations.
Our research acknowledges the polysemy around the concept of voice and is grounded on theoretical perspectives associated with cultural history theory, discourse studies, Pragmatism (Wickman, 2006), and Educational Theory in order to problematise issues such as power, agency and rights in the formulation of research questions, designing instruments and constructing interpretations. Our experience suggests that an explicit focus on voice and representation in educational research results in participant-owned research and consequent reduction of the theory-practice gap.
We start from the recognition that social practices such as educational research and teaching are very diverse in nature, aim and scope. Thus, in spite of sharing goals and concerns, teachers and researchers occupy different social places, possess distinct roles, responsibilities and views about what constitutes knowledge in science education. These differences reflect power asymmetries as well as different degrees of legitimacy and alignment with hegemonic views in the field that must be negotiated throughout the process of collaboration between teachers and researchers. In the end, the two practices need to meet and interact in more productive ways in order for the field of education to become a joint endeavor that unites researchers and practicing teachers towards those interests which they share (Wickman, 2012).
Our results suggest ways forward which are not based on simplified and dichotomous views arguing for either researcher or teacher ownership over the research and development process. Experiences carried out independently in the three countries have shown that research and practice which are carried out within an overall setting that is democratic, collaborative, peer-led, and based on a non-deficit model leads to empowering TPD methodologies and eventually to increased teacher agency (Hamza et al, 2013; Martins forthcoming, 2009; Murphy 2009, 2010). This seems compatible with a view of educational research as fully embedded within educational settings and involving teachers (and children) as participants in all stages of inquiry. This approach foregrounds the rights of participants in forming and expressing views on matters affecting them and problematizes the ways through which researchers as well as teachers are implicated in the process. In other words, it treats research as discursive interaction, involving reflexivity at both personal and epistemic levels (Usher 1996), and analyses appropriation, transformations, as well as of ambivalences and contradictions by the participants in discursive interactions. (Martins 2009)
In this presentation we will share our efforts towards the development of theoretically sound as well as practically functional methodologies, which afford the participant ‘voice’ the opportunity to:
• validate in what form and how data is collected from ‘people like them’;
• explore the range of interpretations of the analysed data from researcher and ‘researched’ perspectives;
• provide ‘360 degree’ conclusions from findings which reflect the community formed by the ‘researched’ and researchers, and;
• develop research which can lead to individual and social transformation in science education contexts
Isabel Martins, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro
Karim Hamza, Stockholm University
Colette Murphy, Trinity College Dublin