Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can We Capture "Everything"? Questioning What Is Left Out in the Research Process

Fri, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Fourth Level, Armitage

Abstract

In this presentation, I will discuss the need for rethinking the representation of research participants and the impact these representations have on analysis and interpretation. I draw on data from a pilot study with children aged 4-6 in Luxembourg. The children videotaped what they thought was interesting during a fieldtrip. I used the process of zooming and focusing (Roth, 2005) to analyze the videos. After I had thought I interpreted the videos in the clearest way possible, I asked the children what they remembered and what they wanted to capture through the videos. Results indicate that the interpretations I assigned to gestures, questions and utterances were (sometimes completely) different to the interpretations the children gave when we watched the videos together.
These findings raise these questions: How are research participants positioned in the research data? What can be done to ensure that the researcher does not misinterpret the video data? When thinking about children as research participants, these questions become even more important because the underlying aspects and meanings of words and gestures might be something completely different from the researcher. What can be done to ensure that the voices of even the youngest participants are heard and valued? Dockett and Perry (2005) suggested that the researcher should go back into the field and show the interpretation to the ones who have been researched.
This presents a methodological challenge for the role of the researcher as “interpreter.” Even if we were to ‘see it all’, does that prevent us from making false interpretations about what we see? What about reflexivity from the researcher’s side and what about the applied methods in/for the children’s and the researcher’s roles? What are the ethical implications of interpreting the other’s actions—in this case, young children? How can we have young children not only as participants but also as research-partners?
While we can never capture it all because of our perspectives and because we are looking for “evidence,” how do we ensure that our interpretations are closer to those participants attach to their lived experiences?
One example for this would be when I was watching a video with a 4-year-old, who explained to me that he was filming the grass to show where milk comes from. Because cows eat grass and then produce milk. I did not even really see this as a significant clip in the multitude of video-data from him. I thought that he filmed this by accident while running around. This taught me to always check with the participants, talk to them about the interpretations and ask them, what “really” happened. This could prevent us as researchers to miss out the important (and sometimes unexpected) results from what we think we captured completely. Using this approach would also ensure that children are not only research object, but included as partners, who are important from the method-selection to the interpretation process.

Key Reference:

Dockett, S. and Perry, B. (2005) ‘Researching with children: Insights from the Starting School Research Project.’ Early Childhood Development and Care 175(6), 523-41.

Author