Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Equity Through Discourse: Supporting Math and Science Discourse in Urban Secondary Classrooms

Mon, April 20, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Third Level, Cook

Abstract

Purpose
To develop equity in classroom pedagogy through the enactment of practice-based teaching by pre-service teachers, specifically content discourse.

Perspectives and Theory
Public Teacher Education Program (Public-TEP) has a mission of social justice and commitment to equity and access. We strive to bridge theory and practice in both dispositions and pedagogical practice. Ball & Forzani (2009) note the critical importance of fostering professional practice in new teachers. Public-TEP characterizes the practice of math and science discourse by several elements including teacher questioning, facilitation and student discourse quality. Specific strategies are suggested to facilitate diversity in student participation, specifically think pair share and talk moves. We focus on discourse because of its strong alignment to both common core and next generation science standards, and more importantly, the potential to develop critical thinking and communication skills in K-12 students. This paper focuses on how Public TEP supports the enactment of discourse practices by pre-service math and science teachers in K-12 classrooms.

Methods
We use equity based classroom observation rubric to collect observational data on discourse throughout the 2013-14 academic year on 11 math and 12 science secondary pre-service teachers. Equity based discourse practices include those that allow diversified student participation in math and science talk such as think pair share, community circles, etc. Each candidate was observed between 5 and 8 times during the academic year. We code reflections based on a discourse focused methods assignment that utilized classroom video analysis for themes (Corbin & Strauss, 2008). Lastly for observational logs, teachers completed daily surveys for five consecutive days where they reported whether they used a discourse strategy (e.g., think-pair-share, re-voicing, write-pair-share).

Preliminary Findings
Observational data, suggest that teacher questioning is strong and the quality of student responses is weak. The observational rounds reflections note the need for specific structures assuring greater participation by a diversity of students. Further, pre-service reflections based on peer video analysis of math or science discourse suggest the importance of norms and embedding supports for English learners. Reflections on specific talk moves are noted, as are teacher facilitation of discourse and student learning. The observational logs note that students are integrating both math talk and science talk over 50 percent of the time over 5 days of instruction.

Scholarly Significance
Equitable discourse practices can provide opportunities for students to practice language and build confidence in a safe space. However this is challenging to do in practice. Given the current educational context, critical thinking and communication are pivotal in education. Equitable discourse can provide a means to make critical thinking visible and practice communication. Our pre-service teachers, like their students, need opportunities to do and analyze their work. Bridging theory and practice is often a monumental feat for beginning teachers. Practice is not devoid of theory and having pre-service teachers analyze their actions and how they leverage student learning is necessary to developing critical transformative educators.

Authors