Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Listening: An Exercise in Communicative Justice

Thu, April 16, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Minnesota

Abstract

Language is a skin: I rub my language against the other. It is as if I had words instead of fingers, or fingers at the tip of my words.
--Roland Barthes

Education exists in communication: teachers with administrators, teachers with students, teachers with parents, students with students, students with parents, and parents with teachers. Such communication comprises an iterative alternation of speakers. If communicating is to be educative, if the participants are to assimilate something of the other's experience, then they must go beyond the egalitarian principle that speaking be fairly distributed—as if this were the only good (Dewey 2008, 9; Barthes 1977, 204). They must listen. If listening is to be as active, deliberate and intelligent as speaking, then what skills, dispositions and understanding does it call upon the listener to exercise? My presentation is an answer this question.

I define listening as an exercise in communicative justice: to listen is to recognize a speaker as meaning what he or she says. It sounds simple enough, but the practice is demanding, for in order to listen, the listener's concepts must be open-textured; that is, they must be available to the permanent possibility of surprise. Cultivating such conceptual availability is difficult. Concepts are established meanings that introduce permanency into an otherwise impermanent world. They correspond to norms that dictate when a concept should be applied and what follows from its application. If the norms are defied, then the communication becomes attenuated. How often do we hear things like: "Our situation is totally different from theirs. They couldn't either of them possibly feel as do either of us.....I cannot take that kind of love seriously" (St John 1997, 28).

Listening entails the reminder that although embedded in a "form of life," concepts are transformed by experience, activity and reflection. Individuals inevitably make a personalized use of their language, developing concepts—whether loyalty, love or integrity - different from those of others. Some of these concepts reveal a profound misunderstanding, whereas others prove to be deeply pedagogical. Thus, Dewey's scientific method, with its emphasis on trial and error, is deeply embedded in our language use.

Listening is an exercise in communicative justice because it requires that the listener receive the speaker as someone who is expressing of his or her particular way of taking up the language (and life), allowing for the recognition that dramatically different ways of speaking and living are embodiments of universally shared concerns. To listen to another is to acknowledge his or her uniqueness. But, the listening does not stop there, for the listener connects with the speaker by attempting to grasp his or her concepts "by the tail." (Barthes 1977, 59). The grasp comes about impressionistically: sense is created by attentively and creatively synthesizing the other's words, phrasings, images, intonations, gestures and expressions. It is by such means that the world is made common and inquiry can begin.

Author