Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teaching as a Listening Profession: Communicative Justice as the Basis for Learning

Thu, April 16, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Minnesota

Abstract

Reframing teaching as a listening profession is a call to transform conceptions of teaching so that children’s learning opportunities are both rigorous and socially just. In this paper I present an empirical study that tests and extends the philosophical ideas of the other panelists. I describe listening that occurs in classrooms as a means to describe how grounding teaching in listening leads to more just interactions. At the heart of this work is the finding that how students are heard matters for their learning. For example, if children are heard primarily to determine if they have the right answer, their opportunities for learning are more limited than if children are heard to make sense of their thinking. When children are heard with curiosity about how they are making sense of what they are learning, teachers - and classmates - have the opportunity to hear ideas from multiple perspectives as well as to hear and make sense of students’ misconceptions. Such listening is the basis for learning through inquiry and discussion.

Listening matters for learning, but it also matters for supporting children to develop practices that lead to social justice. Another finding from this study demonstrates that children learn how to listen and respond to one another based on how they are heard. If students are heard and responded to in responsive and responsible ways, then they learn to respond in responsive and responsible ways. If they are listened to with curiosity then they learn to listen with curiosity, whereas if they are heard with judgment, then they learn to listen with judgment. Curiosity in learning leads to learning and widening the field of what is possible. Judgment tends to limit learning and narrow the field of what is possible. If children learn to listen based on how they are heard, then how teachers listen to children has the potential to influence the interactions and opportunities children have in school and beyond.

In this study, I compare and contrast two upper elementary classrooms to illuminate how these ideas look in practice. I collected video in each classroom for a week, transcribed the interactions that occurred throughout the day and then analyzed the interactions to determine how the teacher and children listened to one another. In addition, I interviewed children and teachers about their ideas about listening and children kept “listening journals” that captured their thoughts about listening throughout the week I was in their class video-taping.

Teaching as a listening profession means grounding our practices in communicative justice (Author, under review), a practice that means children’s thoughts and ideas are heard from the premise that what the student is communicating is worth making sense of. Teaching from listening means inviting broad spectra of thoughts and ideas into the classroom and working to make sense of the spectra together. It means recognizing the reciprocal nature of our interactions in the classroom and working to ensure that all members of the community are responded to in responsive and responsible ways (Biesta, 2006).

Author