Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose. Responding to the contrasting claims of different politicians and advocacy groups, this paper draws on the available research evidence to explore empirically whether or not school reform based on parental choice and school autonomy has worked to the benefit of traditionally disadvantaged groups in English education.
Theoretical Perspective. The paper updates and extends the analysis offered in a major study of the dynamics of the school, the state and the market (Author, 1998), which drew upon wider theories of how a combination of the free market and the strong state operates in other policy fields (Gamble, 1994). That analysis concluded that in practice the neo-liberal and neo-conservative education policies of the Thatcher and Major governments had maintained rather than diminished existing inequalities in England. This paper will utilize more recent data to investigate whether the rather different combination of such policies that has been followed in recent years has had a more progressive effect.
Methods and Data Sources. The paper draws upon the most rigorous evidence available for the period 1998-2014 to ascertain how far the policies enacted by successive Labour and Conservative-led British governments during that period have served, as claimed by their advocates, to narrow or even close the substantial socio-economic achievement gap that has been a longstanding feature of English education. It reviews and interrogates official evaluations and academic analyses of policies such as the national literacy and numeracy strategies, academies (equivalent of US charter schools), Teach First (equivalent of Teach for America), extended (full service) schools, the London Challenge (an area-based intervention), Reading Recovery (an individually targeted intervention), free schools (another version of charter schools) and the ‘pupil premium’ (additional funding to support students from poor families).
Results. The evidence analyzed so far suggests that only a few of these initiatives had a positive impact in terms of narrowing the socio-economic achievement gap. Furthermore, the greatest gains, small as they were, seem to have been derived from initiatives that, in some respects, ran counter to the central thrust of neo-liberal policies that saw school improvement as coming through market competition and parental choice among autonomous schools. The evidence also suggests that some of the gains identified in this period derived more from economic and demographic changes than from specific policy interventions in the field of education.
Significance. The paper uses the best available empirical evidence from a variety of sources to determine the efficacy of policies that are often driven by reformers’ ideological preferences rather than research findings. While accepting that ideological preferences will always influence education policy, the paper casts doubt on some of the empirical claims made to support them. The evident impact of economic and demographic factors on student outcomes counsels against some of the more extravagant claims of both advocates and critics of recent policies and against the notion that fashionable reforms can be expected to ‘work’ in any context.