Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Explaining My Arguments, Explaining Myself: Navigating Disagreement in a Same-Sex Marriage Controversial Political Issue Discussion

Sun, April 19, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Hyatt, Floor: East Tower - Purple Level, Riverside West

Abstract

Disagreement is a necessary dimension of Controversial Political Issue (CPI) discussions and disagreeing brings challenges for students. In this case study I use discourse analysis and discursive psychology to examine the responses of an African American student who found himself in the unenviable position of being the sole opponent to same-sex marriage in a CPI discussion. “Jake” externalized his opinions, managed his self-interest, differentiated between similar ideas, and was systematically vague when necessary. He embraced gay people while opposing gay marriage. This study highlights the difficulties of disagreement for high school students and expands our understanding in what is involved in skillfully putting forward an unpopular opinion.

Author