Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Effects of Dilemma and Personal Relevance on Intergenerational Gameplay Around Video Games

Sat, April 18, 8:15 to 9:45am, Sheraton, Floor: Ballroom Level, Sheraton V

Abstract

Intergenerational play around video games provides unique opportunities for families to connect and learn together (Aarsand, 2007; Horst, 2009). At the same time, the nature of intergenerational play around video games varies across different families, with some parent-child interaction styles and patterns being more conducive for learning than others (Mitchell, 1985; Author and Colleagues, 2010). Using a socio-cultural theoretical framework, this presentation reports on the second iteration of a design-based research study that investigated game designs that support mutual scaffolding between parents and children during intergenerational play. Specifically, the existence of a dilemma situation and a personally relevant narrative was tested.

Expanding the notion of zone of proximal development, Newman, Griffin, and Cole (1989) define adult-child problem solving as a “construction zone” where two minds meet. This non-material space is neither solely created by the adult nor solely by the child, but emerges through a process of joint constructive interaction mediated by common goals, and involves parents and children providing assistance to one another as they work through the problem.

Sixteen mother-child pairs (children ages 9 to 13) played through different video game scenarios designed within Quest Atlantis, a three-dimensional educational gaming environment (www.QuestAtlantis.Org), in an after school site. All pairs completed an introductory game scenario, and then were randomly assigned to one of the two treatment combinations by the game system. Each condition involved two game scenarios that varied along the dimensions of dilemma and personal relevance. Data sources include parent questionnaires, video recordings of parent-child gameplay, and semi-structured interviews with parents and children about their experiences playing together. A list of eleven assistance behaviors were identified, applied to conversation data, and coded for the parent and the child separately. Mutual assistance was calculated by taking the difference between the frequency counts of the parent and the child on each assistance behavior.

Three separate repeated measures MANOVAs were conducted for parent, child, and mutual assistance behaviors to understand the effects of dilemma and personal relevance. A univariate ANOVA was used to follow up on significant MANOVA tests. Personal relevance had no significant effect on parent, child, or mutual assistance behaviors. Dilemma had significant effect only on parent assistance behaviors (F(1, 32) = 5.723, p<.05). Mothers pointed out information that was relevant to the task significantly more during non-dilemma scenarios than dilemma scenarios (F(1, 32) = 6.695, p<.05). Mothers gave more directives during non-dilemma scenarios than dilemma scenarios (F(1, 32) = 5.834, p<.05). The final presentation will discuss the implications of quantitative findings coupled with qualitative examples of mutual assistance between parents and children during gameplay for supporting intergenerational play, learning, and connection.

Results from this study contribute to our understanding of the nature of computer-mediated communication and learning between parents and children, and how to design learning experiences for families in the context of video games that position parents and children as learning partners.

Author