Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Designing Service-Learning to Foster Cultural Humility Among Preservice Teachers

Mon, April 20, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott, Floor: Third Level, Cook

Abstract

This presentation documents a community-initiated service-learning project within a teacher education program. A social justice model guided the initiative to raise critical awareness on power and privilege while countering deficit-model thinking. Cultural competency training programs can be problematic because they promote a perspective that professionals should reach a point where they can demonstrate their mastery of a finite body of intercultural knowledge, make sense of the “other,” and master particular static cultures that have core characteristics (Guo, Arthur, & Lund, 2009). Partnering with community agencies serving immigrant children and youth, the researcher and research assistant worked with a campus office for community-engaged learning to modify a required “Diversity in Learning” course to include service-learning (Butin, 2010) but from a cultural humility perspective, adapted from medicine (Tervalon & Murray-Garcia, 1998). By adopting a social justice framework for course readings, curricular materials, and assignments, the professor afforded students an ability to engage with a range of diversity themes and concepts in a manner that foregrounded issues of oppression, power, and privilege (Cipolle, 2010; Megivern, 2010; Sensoy & DiAngelo, 2012).

This research is derived from 21 recorded interviews, 21 completed survey questionnaires, and seminar observations with 11 of 27 students enrolled in a diversity education course; other data included field notes collected during interviews with community placement mentors over a 10-week period. Themes were coded and clustered along recurrent topics based on protocols of critical ethnography (Madison, 2012), with the researcher and research assistant providing data triangulation on the eventual key emergent themes.

Findings showed benefits from this justice-based approach in improving self-awareness, appreciating the strengths of immigrant children and youth, and an increased sense of cultural humility in pre-service teachers. Specifically, our analysis of the data suggests that the combination of practical experiences provided through the community placements, the theoretical investigation facilitated through the course, and the personal and in-class reflective activities woven throughout the program, supported pre-service teachers in making connections between theory and practical experiences, engaging in self-critique and self-reflection, negotiating their position, power, privileges, and assumptions, and investing in the bi-directional process of building relationships with children and youth of immigrant families.

Several illustrations indicate various ways pre-service teachers express their learning from justice-based service-learning experiences. For example, their accounts pointed to the importance of cultural humility approaches being crafted for a wide range of motivations, life experiences, and understandings of diversity. Likewise, social justice-based approaches improve pre-service teachers’ ability to identify and appreciate the many strengths of children and youth of immigrant families, and foster in them a sense of cultural humility and greater self-awareness. In sum, the pre-service teachers interviewed offered evidence of an increased sense of cultural humility, and understanding of the teacher’s pivotal role in creating more equitable learning experiences for all children and youth, including those from immigrant families. Findings suggest that professional education faculties can strengthen their service-learning experiences by eschewing deficit-model thinking and cultural competency approaches, and increasing their focus on fostering cultural humility, critical engagement, and reflection on social justice issues.

Authors