Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

School Librarian Voices

Fri, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, St. Gallen 3

Abstract

Multiple studies show that school librarians positively impact student learning (for example, Hay and Todd, 2010), including the improvement of reading scores of students in schools with a certified librarian across socio-economic groups (Lance and Hofschire, 2012). School librarians are encouraged by the the professional literature to promote these studies and keep their schools and communities aware of their accomplishments through advocacy (Lance and Hofschire, 2012).

In spite of this, school librarians are largely invisible within the field of education. The work that librarians do is often behind the scenes: scaffolding the research process, teaching resource evaluation skills, information literacy and digital literacy skills. Yet, since librarians scaffold teacher-driven assignments, their contributions are often not visible. Hartzell (2002) cites librarians’ supportive roles as contributing to their “invisibility problem”. This invisibility places the librarian in a paradoxical position in our assessment-driven culture. When your work is scaffolding the process, how can it be measured? What test scores can be linked to your effectiveness? When the work you are scaffolding for students is not assessed by you, how can a product be directly linked to your teaching?

To combat the invisibility problem of school librarians, it is crucial that their voices be heard on these questions. It is also vital that school librarians participate in the dialogue about the future of the library profession as it pertains to education. In order to contribute to this discourse, the School Librarian Voices project asks school librarians to reflect on their work in the library, what they view their role to be, and how they see these elements changing during the current era of education reform.

Twenty school librarians from New York State who have been in the profession for at least three years were interviewed for the School Librarian Voices project. New York is a significant site for education policy change, as it is one of a handful of states to rapidly adopt significant changes with heavy emphasis on value-added assessment mandated by participation in Race To The Top. Study participants responded to questions about their work, their identity as school librarians and how both have changed over time, given the changing educational climate. Interviews were coded according to the literature on both the perceptions of school librarians (Hartzell, 2002; Shannon, 2012) as well as for beliefs about students, teaching, learning, literacy, technology, resistance (to policy, general change or conflict) (Achinstein and Ogawa, 2006). Early findings indicate that while some school librarians are nostalgic for past concepts of the librarian role, others are working toward redefining that role in ways that challenge current norms. In both cases, groups are using a multitude of strategies to promote their work within schools and communities. The findings of this study are significant in rethinking the role of the school librarian, and will also help educators rethink the importance of process-driven practices in shaping future policy.

Author