Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Self-Fulfilling Prophecy or Accurate Prediction? Exploring the Relationship Between Teacher Perceptions and Student Achievement

Fri, April 17, 4:05 to 5:35pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Northwestern/Ohio State

Abstract

Research in psychology and education has explored the extent to which teachers’ perceptions of students’ aptitude and other characteristics (e.g., behavior) are related to the actual achievement of their students. Although associations between teacher perceptions and student achievement could arise via a number of different mechanisms, one of the most commonly explored is that of self-fulfilling prophecy. Self-fulfilling prophecy theory suggests that teachers’ perceptions of and expectations for their students are correlated with student achievement not because teachers accurately perceive student aptitude, but because teacher expectations result in differential treatment of students, leading to altered outcomes (Jussim, 1989; Alvidrez & Weinstein, 1999; Jussim & Harber, 2005).

Teachers’ perceptions of their students could also impact student achievement if these perceptions change other teacher behaviors. For example, if teachers are more likely to participate in professional development when they find their students to be more difficult to teach, their students might do better than they otherwise would. As such, it is important to understand not only whether teacher perceptions matter for student outcomes, but also how they might matter.

To explore the importance of teacher perceptions, we use data from 246 teachers participating in a national study on teacher effectiveness. On a fall questionnaire administered each year, teachers were asked to compare “this year’s class” to “last year’s class” on four different measures: behavior, preparedness, learning difficulties, and overall difficulty to teach. From the four questions measuring teacher perceptions, we create a single factor of “class difficulty” on which we regress teacher value-added at the end of the year.

The baseline model has teacher value-added as an outcome and class difficulty as a predictor, and also includes a number of control variables typically thought to be associated with teacher value-added, including degree status, years of experience, and value-added in the previous year. In this model, class difficulty is a statistically significant predictor of teacher value-added. When students’ average prior achievement is added to the model, however, the association between teachers’ perceptions and value-added becomes insignificant.

One possible interpretation of these results is that the effects of self-fulfilling prophecy in education research may be overstated. Our analyses show that the relationship between teachers’ perceptions of students and student achievement disappears when controlling for actual characteristics of the students, suggesting that perceptions might be correlated with outcomes simply by virtue of teachers accurately perceiving characteristics of their students: teachers are able to accurately assess the difficulty of their classes, and these assessments then predict value-added. Though student outcomes may not be caused by the self-fulfilling prophecy phenomenon, these findings also indicate that teachers do not exceed expectations when teaching difficult classes. Instead, their value-added is consistently lower when they find their classes more challenging to teach. Future analyses will test the relationship between teacher perceptions and teacher behaviors to explore whether a correlation (or lack thereof) between perceptions and behaviors might explain the correlation between teacher perceptions and student achievement.

Author