Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Paradox of Visibility: Families Impacted by Homphobia, Heterosexism, and Transphobia in Schools

Mon, April 20, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Lincolnshire

Abstract

Parents who are themselves (Casper & Schultz, 1999; Garner, 2004; Goldberg, 2010; Pallotta-Chiarelli, 2010) or who have LGBTQQ or gender creative children often feel fearful, unwelcomed, or silenced in their children’s schools (Fischer & Kennedy, 2012; Kozik-Rosabal, 2000; Lipkin, 1999; Walling, 1996). Given these issues, and given that the problems of sexual identity- and gender-based hostility and abuse persist in school environments, this paper focuses on queer parents raising gender creative students and address these research questions: How are families that are headed by lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans*, or queer parents experiencing support and non-support in schools? How are families with children who identify as LGBTQQ or who are gender creative experiencing support and non-support in schools? Purposive sampling (Patton, 1990) was used in order to identify information-rich cases that exemplify the key foci of our inquiry. Data included audiotaped and transcribed interviews. Interviews were coded and analyzed using a grounded approach and constant comparison (Strauss & Corbin, 1998). Although we conducted interviews with straight identifying parents of LGBTQQ students and queer parents of students who do not identify with any part of the acronym, we decided to focus on this subset of interviews because we have something important to learn from parents who have insights on being queer based on their own experiences that might inform their parenting of gender creative kids. With this commitment, we identified five interviews representing three families, each with one child. Among the themes we found through our analysis was the paradox of visibility. That is, queer parents and their gender creative kids expressed a desire to be a part of communities where they can see and be with other people like themselves. They, particularly the young people, though, understood a certain vulnerability with being seen as something other than gender conforming, whether they were being seen in private spaces like bathrooms and locker rooms or in public ones, like school buses. Moreover, they understood the security of being seen as part of a heteronormative family or being seen as gender normative. They are even willing to suffer consequences to avoid being seen, whether in the bathroom or more generally speaking, as gender non-conforming. Based on these themes, we suggest that educators must work to make connections among students with queer-headed households and/or among those who are gender creative with a sensitivity to the fact that some times visibility is desired but other times it is not. They must also work not to underscore the false dichotomy of gender by organizing their students in those terms. Further, they must educate students about diverse constructions of family and gender expressions. They must teach the difference between sex and gender, and they must teach gender creative kids to love and stand up for themselves.

Authors