Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Research in Initial Teacher Education: Defining the Paths

Sat, April 18, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Hyatt, Floor: East Tower - Purple Level, Riverside West

Abstract

Research in Initial Teacher Education: Defining the Paths

Objectives

Teacher education programs should be informed by research and preservce teachers should engage in research activities. With the increased diversity among our students, there is a critical need to prepare teachers with an ethically informed stance regarding empirical inquiry and democratized knowledge. This study has investigated research and inquiry across teacher education programs in one country. All programs are legally bound by the same legislation stipulating a main outcome: that they qualify students for “research based work.” What this means, however, is not clear. The study provides insight into how “research based teacher education” is perceived among teacher educators and their students, and how programs are designed for undergraduate research in teacher education.

Perspectives

Undergraduate research is one means to address the challenge of developing necessary skills for a complex workplace and to advance the scholarship agenda of the teaching profession (Hodge, Pasquesi, Hirsh 2007). However, the role of research in undergraduate education is still not clear. The methods for involving students in undergraduate research, topics covered, and even the concept of what undergraduate research is, vary between disciplines, colleges, and universities (Gomez, 2013).

Healey (2005) has developed a four-factor model with two intersecting axes (the content continuum and the agent continuum) to illustrate a research-based undergraduate education. The horizontal axis represents the content continuum and goes from having an emphasis on research content to emphasizing research processes and problems. The agent continuum is concerned with students’ engagement with academic reading and writing, their engagement with learning about and discussing research literature, learning about research methods and using inquiry and research methods in their own projects or in participation with teachers’ projects.

Methods

An interview study conducted at six (out of 19 possible) strategically selected institutions with 6 teacher educators and 6 third year students at each (36 teacher educators and 36 students total).

Data

Transcribed interviews and excel forms.

Results

There is great variation in how qualified teacher educators consider research and their conditions for taking part in research. Variation was also evident between students’ and teachers’ perceptions especially in relation to research literature.

The programs studied do not yet have a coherent design to qualify students to work in “research based (or informed) ways.” All programs emphasized observation during the first field placement period (semester 1 out of a total of 8), a small “research-like project” during year two, and preparation for the BA thesis in semesters 4 and 5 (to be completed in semester 6), but there was no agreement among teacher educators about what this goal meant nor how to reach it. Questions of ethical inquiry, why or how to qualify at the program level were not raised as issues by teacher educators.

Scientific significance

This is the first comprehensive study of undergraduate research in Initial Teacher Education. It questions what a research based program can be and the need for program design.

Authors