Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper analyzes how teaching a historical event that focuses on Mexican Americans’ claim to legal White racial status helps students challenge simplistic notions of racial discrimination. Bridging the work on historical thinking (Seixas, 1993; Wineburg, 2001) and research on the unsophisticated representation of race and ethnicity in U.S. history (Banks 2002; Foster 1999; Garcia, 1993; Wills, 1996), this paper examines the affordances and limitations that occur when students draw on their own personal experiences to make sense of racial discrimination in the past.
The findings from this paper draw on a three-day lesson on Mendez v. Westminster School District, a case about 1940s Mexican American school segregation. The observations took place in two 11th grade U.S. history classrooms in a predominantly Latino/a California Bay Area school. In addition to field notes, data collection also included 177 student work samples, four teacher interviews and fifteen 40-minute student interviews.
Following a grounded theory approach (Glaser & Strauss, 1967), the data was open coded, then triangulated across three data sources (field notes, student work, and student interviews). I identified two group codes that the three data sources shared in common. These guide my findings and analytical discussion.
The data analysis revealed that centering the narrative of the Mendez case around the role of racial constructs opened up a space for conversation regarding race to occur. Specifically, it allowed students to bring in their own experiences with race and ethnicity to guide them in their analysis on race, ethnicity, and race relations in 1940s California. Students commented on how Whiteness comes with a set of advantages, in this case, access to White schools. Their understanding of how racial categories, racial constructs, and white privilege function in the present, allowed them to be empathetic to Mexican Americans in the 1940s who chose White as their racial categories. Students understood that it was a strategy to gain access.
Students were able to use their personal experiences to make sense of Whiteness and its privileges. However, these same experiences interfered with students understanding how language segregation was used as a proxy for racial discrimination against Mexican Americans. Overwhelmingly, students imposed a presentist understanding of language education onto 1940s language segregation. Students assumed that Mexican Americans who were segregated were being accommodated with additional instructional materials and teacher assistance to help students learn English. Students struggled to place the language segregation decision in a historical and racial context that allowed them to understand that language could be used as a proxy for racial/ethnic discrimination.
This paper offers implications for social studies pedagogy, specifically reexamining 1) the way we introduce students to historical events regarding race/ethnicity; and 2) how to draw on students prior knowledge to lead more nuanced conversations about racial discrimination.