Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Majorities and Minorities

Mon, April 11, 7:45 to 9:15am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 146 B

Abstract

The editors have noted that “minorities” are defined differently in the North and in Latin America. This paper aims to discuss a related point—the different and changing approaches to education for majorities and minorities in two contrasting countries within Latin America: Brazil and Peru. Whilst in Brazil the indigenous population is a very small proportion of the national population (about 0.2 percent), in Peru it is a larger one: officially about 18 percent, although some measures indicate it could be even 40 percent depending on the criteria used to measure. Moreover, indigenous or other “minorities” may be “regional majorities” in certain regions, communities and even schools. In both contexts, therefore, different approaches have been used to deal with education of indigenous groups depending on whether they are considered as majorities or minorities, although these concepts are not necessarily used consistently.

The evolving nature of both concepts and the social, cultural and political changes in both countries (and also globally) have affected the way demands for education for indigenous groups are currently faced. Majorities in Peru, for example, find it easier nowadays to claim their educational (and other) rights if acting as minorities, or using laws inspired by the concept of indigenous groups as minorities. Brazil on the other hand has treated indigenous groups as minorities but at the same time has paid little attention to their needs and demands, many times proposing policies that treat them as what is considered as the major (or majority) problem—poverty. Indigenous people instead declare that they do not intend to be included in the hegemonic system, asking to keep their own orientations, first of all presence on the land and territory its usage. Ethnographic studies of education in both countries can reveal these dynamics and the continued need to review the concepts used in the field.

Authors