Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

An Empirical Test of A–F School Grades

Mon, April 11, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level Two, Exhibit Hall D

Abstract

We used 201-2012 and 2012-2013 math and reading student test scores from 61 elementary and middle schools in a large urban school district to test the effectiveness of a state’s school accountability A-F grading. We estimated achievement effects between students in “A”/”B” schools and students in either “C”, “D”, or “F” schools, and we estimated school-level differences in achievement gaps. Achievement differences between letter grades were small and generally non-significant controlling for student and school characteristics. Achievement gaps within high ranked schools were masked; free/reduced lunch and minority students in “D” and “F” schools outperformed peers in “A” and “B” schools. Poor and minority students are left behind when grades obscure achievement differences within schools.

Authors