Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Making Across Spaces: Madison Public Library's System-Wide Approach

Mon, April 11, 4:30 to 6:00pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 101

Abstract

While the term makerspace typically refer to a singular location allocated for maker activities (e.g. Sheridan et al., 2014), Madison Public Libraries has built “the Bubbler” - a flexible programing model designed to serve the network of nine neighborhood library communities and their needs. Our research seeks to understand this system-wide approach to making that is embedded in the Bubbler program. The focus of this study is to develop ‘Neighborhood Library Profiles’ as a method of understanding how individual library communities are incorporating making into their core services and practices.

Halverson and Sheridan’s (2014) essay sets the stage for research on the maker movement in education, highlighting three key components that can be used to frame research questions, design decisions, and policy making: making as a set of activities, makerspaces as communities of practice, and makers as identities of participation. We focus on makerspaces constructed over time at the intersection of people, space, tools, and practices. In this way, the concept of makerspace can extend far beyond a single physical space to communities of practice (Lave & Wenger, 1991), which can span across spaces as participants come together and participate in a range of making activities.

Our study takes a design-based research approach (DBRC, 2003) as we investigate the development of this system-wide model and collaboratively redesign maker programming. DBR enables us to engage in an iterative cycle of data collection and design that continually informs the development and implementation of new designs to foster robust communities of practice and community involvement.

To construct our Neighborhood Library Profiles we collected a range of data aiming to capture the culture of the nine spaces and the system as a whole. We analyzed data from a system-wide social network survey (Daley, 2010), interviews with all the MPL staff and librarians involved in Bubbler programming and implementation, focus groups, and extensive observations in order to create individual case studies of each neighborhood library and to map out the system for shared structures and learning arrangements. This non-linear approach honors the way in which the Bubbler is physically and programmatically localized and acknowledges the emergent and recursive processes and supporting the inherent fluidity of library programming.

This research shows the diverse range of definitions and practices throughout the neighborhood libraries. We will share our network maps as well as the individual neighborhood profiles as a way of explicating how a system-wide approach values both diversity and inclusivity of the range of makers who participate in the Bubbler and learning arrangements that facilitate making.

As public libraries embrace their role as transformational spaces, more often serving as host to making and community building activities, they also have the ability to positively impact and democratize the maker movement. However, as public libraries establish maker programming, there is a need to know more about participation in these spaces and how to develop a system-wide approach. From this study new theories and models are emerging around how library systems can conceptualize maker programming beyond individual in-house library makerspaces.

Authors