Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Critical Race Theory Content Analysis of a High School African American Studies Curriculum

Mon, April 11, 10:00 to 11:30am, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Two, Marquis Salon 16

Abstract

A primary aim of the social studies is the preparation of effective, competent, and critically aware citizens. This call implies that issues of race and racism should be included in the content of social studies. However, scholarly research has shown that discussions of race and racism are notably omitted within the curriculum and policies of the social studies. Consequently, the social studies cannot promote citizenship and democracy when it fails to acknowledge and recognize the historical and contemporary role of race and racism on the very exercise of citizenship. To address these omissions and marginalization in the curriculum, ethnic studies courses like African American Studies were introduced in the late 1960s and early 1970s. These courses sought to challenge the misrepresentations and inaccuracies of African Americans and confront race and racism. Furthermore, these courses promoted critical thinking as they questioned the role and influence of systemic and hierarchical power not only on race but on other aspects of identity such as class, gender, and sexuality. Unfortunately, there is a dearth of scholarly literature and research that examines the curriculum of African American Studies.

This paper reports the findings of a critical race theory content analysis of a High School African American Studies curriculum. An analysis of two sources, an adopted textbook for African American Studies and the Essential Standards (a curriculum guide of standards for the course as designed by the State of North Carolina) was conducted through the lens of CRT to understand how race and racism are examined and discussed in curriculum materials. In addition to exploring race and racism, connections between race and citizenship and the impact of racism on the full exercise of citizenship was examined and analyzed. A CRT analysis of the curriculum materials included the following: 1) a critical examination of historical topics that did and did not address race and racism, 2) an exploration for elements of counter-storytelling, 3) evidence of the curriculum challenging the dominant ideology presented in the standard curriculum, and 4) examples within the narrative of the text of meritocracy, interest convergence, and incremental change.

Findings from the study revealed that race and racism was not explicitly addressed in the adopted textbook and the Essential Standards. When race and racism appeared it was distorted, diluted, and decontextualized. Direct connections between race and citizenship were acknowledged in the textbook, but no in the Essential Standards. The impact of racism on the full exercise of citizenship was expressed in an implicit manner in both the textbook and the Essential Standards. A CRT analysis and discussion highlighted what was included and missing in both the adopted textbook and the Essential Standards and its implication for social studies education. Future research suggests a detailed and careful examination and analysis on the teaching of African American Studies and its impact on student learning.



 

Author