Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Migrant Education Program: A Critical Historical Analysis

Sat, April 9, 8:15 to 9:45am, Convention Center, Floor: Level Two, Exhibit Hall D Section B

Abstract

This paper presents a critical historical analysis of policy considered key to the formation of the Migrant Education Program (MEP) in the U.S. The objectives are three-fold: (a) to delineate the political-economic forces that lead to the advent of MEP; (b) to identify the discourses that make MEP possible; and (c) to provide a political cartography for advocates working within and against state institutions in their advocacy for familias migrantes.
The War on Poverty (1964) and the Civil Rights Movement created spaces for advocates to push for the inclusion of migrant families. While scholars have maintained that anti-poverty programs tend to reproduce existing racial structures (Danielson, 2013), others argue that that they reinscribe deficit discourses about racial and economic “others” (Kainz & Aikens, 2007). We draw on racial apartheid theories of the state (Goldberg, 2002; Omi & Winant, 1994) and interest convergence theory (Bell, 1980), as critical tools for analyzing policy formation in the context of the migrant community.
The questions guiding our content analysis are: What makes MEP possible? How is the “migrant” child constituted in key policy and cultural texts? How is the education of the migrant child and family circumscribed by racist discourses at the state-policy level? Using these two overarching theoretical lenses, we proceed with a content analysis using thematic coding of key concepts that encircle and define the migrant child, the migrant family, the education of the migrant community, and the migrant advocate. We then reposition these concepts in relation to each other, leading to axial coding that identifies larger “tropes” or narratives that begin to answer our overarching questions.
We analyze key policy documents and texts, such as the Congressional sessions that led to the formation of MEP in 1966, federal and state-level policy documents that directly impact migrant families, and key documentaries representing migrant families, including select published scholarship, which is quite useful in analyzing the ways in which “tropes” and narratives are (re)framed and (re)constituted within racial frameworks.
Our content analysis has led us to the identification of four major tropes or narratives:
• The migrant child as becoming through economic “salvation” yet dependent upon migrant policies and advocacy;
• The migrant family as culturally and economically deprived;
• The education of the migrant community as both necessary and sufficient;
• The migrant advocate as “liberator”, yet deliverer of “services.”

Results suggest that the migrant community is constituted by racist discourses. Moreover, the categories used to define the migrant community serve as delimiting rather than liberating strategies. Viewed critically and reflexively, our analysis points not towards abandoning hope in change within institutions that have a long-standing tradition of racism embedded in them, but to rethink our strategies for hope and solidarity within and against all the spaces of our advocacy.

Authors