Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Remembering/Forgetting the Music City: Performative Place-Making With Diverse Publics

Tue, April 12, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 144 C

Abstract

Cities are remembered and forgotten by being told and retold over time (Massey, 2005). Participating in telling requires access to information, legitimate rights to telling, and practices of layering together story lines that (selectively) preserve meaning and are (more or less) just (Soja, 2010). We report on ethnographic and design studies of diverse publics (youth, adults residents, and professionals) telling about their desires and experiences in a highly segregated, southern US city with a deep history of civil rights activism and American Roots music. We analyze telling (remembering and forgetting) the Music City as place-making performances that create new layers of public history.

Our objective is to describe how place-making performances manage persistent pressures on sense making and intersubjectivity (Schegloff, 1992), resulting in layers of coordinated if not entirely shared meanings. We start with an ethnography of public participation in city planning, then use findings to develop a series of design studies of youth using locative technologies and city archives to tell the Music City, in some cases talking/mapping back to city officials (AU1 & AU2, 2013).

We take a sociocultural perspective on learning and teaching in place-making performances, consistent with theories of mediated action (Wertsch, 1998) and learning in social practice (e.g., Lave & Wenger, 1990). We focus on multi-modal analysis of place-making performance, both on the surface of maps and as people move through the city, looking at how talk, body movement, tool use, and spatial representations are assembled (AU2 & XX, in press; Hutchins, 1995). Specifically, we ask how the sequential organization of telling (or doing) stories with dynamic maps provides for diverse public understanding of Music City neighborhoods and their cultural and economic history.

Data are video recordings of map-based, story telling interactions that involve youth, adult residents, and professional planners in design charrettes (Sutton & Kemp, 2002) and mobile map/tour making activities that we designed. We use participant observation, interviewing, and analysis of digital products (e.g., story lines and geo-located media) to understand the interactive work of place-making performances and what people learn in these activities.

Our analysis supports several findings: (a) While telling the city in charrette or tour making/following, speakers and listeners take positions with varied “modal congruence” for time, social relations, and moral stance (AU1, 2013); (b) Modal congruence influences how what is told/remembered “reaches the map” as a durable/reusable record (i.e., making places accessible later, by others); and (c) Digital mapping tools can be used to tell/follow spatial story lines as a new form of mobile, public engagement with the city and its history.

These findings have implications for understanding of place-making as a form of learning and teaching. They also ground further development of tools and environments for creating digital spatial story lines as a conceptual practice of remember/forgetting public history with rich possibilities for learning and teaching.

Authors