Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Impact of Online Versus F2F Algebra Credit Recovery

Sat, April 9, 4:05 to 6:05pm, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Two, Marquis Salon 2

Abstract

Purpose
This paper presents results from a randomized control trial designed to assess the impact of online versus f2f credit recovery in Algebra I. The study, through a grant from the U.S. Department of Education, provided resources to Chicago high schools to implement credit recovery courses during the summers of 2011 and 2012 to ninth graders who failed Algebra I in their first year of high school. Students were randomly assigned to take Algebra I as either an online course or as a f2f course.

Theoretical Framework
The theory behind the study is that students fail algebra because they have low incoming skills, are poorly engaged, and exert little effort. Students learn little and subsequently fail. Without understanding algebra, they struggle in subsequent math courses. Students then have insufficient credits to graduate, and eventually drop out. Online credit recovery is hypothesized to interrupt this process by reengaging students via a more individualized, interactive experience with personal support from both an online teacher and an on-site mentor, thus leading to success in algebra and later success in subsequent courses.

Methods and Data Sources
The study employs an experimental design with student-level random assignment to either online or f2f Algebra I credit recovery courses in CPS high schools. The study took place in 17 CPS high schools with relatively high Algebra I failure rates.

A total of 1,224 first-time freshmen participated in summer 2011 or 2012. They were randomly assigned by the study team to take either the online course or a f2f course on the first day of summer school.

The online course was developed by Aventa Learning. Students took the course in computer labs at their local high schools, with a trained on-site mentor. They also had an online algebra teacher, provided by Aventa. The control condition was the typical f2f Algebra IB course offered in participating schools, taught by a licensed CPS teacher.

The study uses achievement, course-taking, and graduation data available via district administrative records. Short-term outcomes were obtained via primary data collection during the summer sessions, including student survey measures and an end-of-course algebra posttest.

Results
Results show that most study students (71%) in both the online and f2f conditions successfully recovered algebra credit; there were some short-term benefits for f2f over online credit recovery; and no differences on longer-term outcomes. The online course was perceived by students as more difficult and less clear than the f2f algebra credit recovery course, and students in the f2f course had higher grades, higher pass rates, and scored significantly higher on an algebra posttest than students in the online course. However there were no significant differences by condition on any measured outcomes during the second or the third year of high school. Graduation outcomes will be in-hand for all study students by November 2015 and will be included in the presentation.

Scholarly Significance
This paper will present findings through high school graduation of the only rigorous study of credit recovery conducted to date.

Authors